Lt. Richard Goerling, Mindfulness in Police Work
Police Lieutenant Richard Goerling discusses how mindfulness training helps law enforcement officers reduce stress, improve decision-making, regulate emotions, and mitigate implicit bias. He shares his journey of adapting mindfulness for police culture and its impact on individual officers and systemic change.
Deep Dive Analysis
15 Topic Outline
Mindfulness as a Constructive Element in Policing
Richard Goerling's Journey to Mindfulness and Motivation
Initial Experience with MBSR and Adapting it for Police
Defining the 'Warrior Ethos' in Policing
Overcoming Barriers to Implement Mindfulness Training
Early Research Findings on Mindfulness for Police
Mindfulness and Mitigating Implicit Bias in Law Enforcement
Challenges in Testing Cognitive Bias in Police Officers
Systemic Influences on Police Behavior and Individual Impact
Officer Demeanor and its Effect on Citizen Encounters
The Tactical Benefits of Awareness and Compassion
Developing Effective Training Models for Police Logistics
Expanding Mindfulness Training to Diverse Police Departments
Richard Goerling's Personal Mindfulness Practice
Personal Transformation and Role as a Change Agent
7 Key Concepts
Asshole Factor (Police Context)
This refers to police officers unintentionally acting tough, overly guarded, tense, or directive, leading to negative interactions. This behavior is often a stress response, fostering a culture of negativity and judgment among officers.
Post-Traumatic Growth
This concept suggests that individuals can navigate through traumatic experiences and, with a period of adjustment, emerge stronger than they were before. It offers an alternative perspective to solely focusing on post-traumatic stress disorder.
Vicarious Resilience
This is the idea that individuals can gain strength and resilience by observing others successfully cope with and overcome adversity. It highlights the positive impact of witnessing others' successful navigation of challenges.
Regulating Emotion (vs. Controlling)
Mindfulness teaches the skill of becoming aware of emotions and managing the body's stress response, rather than attempting to suppress or control feelings. Emotions are a natural function of the brain, and the goal is to navigate them skillfully.
Warrior Ethos (Police Context)
In policing, this refers to an officer who protects public safety and democracy, responding to crises in a meaningful and useful way without exacerbating the situation. It emphasizes being capable and effective while maintaining compassion and avoiding unnecessary harm.
Implicit Bias (Police Context)
These are subconscious assumptions or narratives police officers may form about individuals, often based on factors like race, which can lead to disproportionate enforcement actions or use of force. Mindfulness is proposed as a method to increase awareness of and mitigate such biases.
Dojo (Training Context)
Borrowed from martial arts, this term is used to describe a dedicated, sacred space for training. In this context, it refers to a place where police officers can engage in mindfulness practice and skill development.
8 Questions Answered
He began formal meditation training about 10 years ago, driven by a desire to improve police performance and address cynicism among officers, rather than personal anguish. He discovered mindfulness after initially exploring emotional intelligence.
While recognized as helpful, the standard 8-week MBSR course contained elements perceived as 'touchy-feely' that were not well-suited for direct implementation within police culture, necessitating significant modification.
Due to constant exposure to tragic events, officers often resort to judging others (e.g., citizens) as a coping mechanism to make sense of their experiences. This practice fosters a culture of negativity, judgment, and cynicism, often as an unconscious stress response.
Yes, based on current research and expert belief, mindfulness is considered a crucial pathway to becoming aware of implicit biases. Once recognized, these biases can be mitigated through increased awareness and the cultivation of compassion.
Research indicates that an officer's negative attitude or authoritative approach can escalate encounters, leading to a greater likelihood of force response and enforcement actions. A calm, compassionate demeanor can de-escalate situations.
While it might seem tactically safer in isolated moments, chronic hypervigilance and unregulated stress from such a demeanor lead to significant long-term health risks. Mindfulness, by enhancing awareness and cognitive decision-making, actually improves tactical safety.
The operational challenges of police shifts and logistics make it difficult to ensure consistent attendance for eight separate training sessions. Furthermore, significant buy-in from officers often doesn't occur until later in the course, making initial engagement challenging.
He describes himself as an 'evolved person,' possessing greater self-awareness, increased compassion for others, and reduced judgment. These changes have positively impacted his personal interactions, parenting, and his effectiveness as a change agent in policing.
15 Actionable Insights
1. Mindfulness for Performance & Safety
Use mindfulness to reduce stress, make better tactical decisions, combat prejudice, and reduce unnecessary force, ultimately improving performance and safety by fostering awareness and compassion.
2. Regulate Emotions, Don’t Suppress
Learn to regulate emotions like frustration, anger, and fear by becoming aware of them, rather than ignoring or compartmentalizing, which can lead to negative outbursts.
3. Combat Implicit Bias with Awareness
Employ mindfulness as a pathway to become aware of implicit biases, and then mitigate them through increased awareness and compassion, leading to fairer interactions.
4. Officer Demeanor Impacts Outcomes
Understand that an officer’s demeanor (e.g., authoritative, ‘asshole’ approach) can escalate situations, leading to a greater incidence of force or enforcement, while compassion improves safety and performance.
5. Recognize and Reduce Judgment
Be aware of the tendency to judge others, especially in stressful environments, as this coping mechanism fosters negativity and cynicism, which is unhealthy for individuals and community relations.
6. Tailor Mindfulness Training Culturally
When implementing mindfulness training in specific cultures (e.g., law enforcement), modify content by removing ’touchy-feely’ elements, adding ‘gritty’ aspects, and incorporating relevant practices like movement and a ‘warrior ethos’.
7. Socialize New Ideas with Science
To gain acceptance for new initiatives like mindfulness, spend time socializing the scientific basis (neuroscience) with peers and key leaders, establishing a groundwork for understanding and buy-in.
8. Embrace Fluid Personal Meditation
Adopt a flexible and varied personal meditation practice, which can include short formal sits (10-15 minutes), intentional walking, or integrating mindfulness into daily activities like swimming, making it realistic and sustainable.
9. Seek Intensive Mindfulness Retreats
Supplement daily practice with formal intensive retreats (e.g., a 5-day or weekend retreat annually) as these provide profound benefits and can be ’life-saving’ for sustained well-being.
10. Step Outside System for Change
If internal criticism or new ideas are not accepted within an institution, consider finding external platforms (e.g., adjunct faculty) to present alternative perspectives and drive change, operating with one foot inside and one foot outside the system.
11. Be a Bridge Builder for Change
When advocating for systemic change, position yourself as a bridge between diverse communities (e.g., academia, law enforcement, community activists) to foster conversation and build relationships, even if it’s a challenging and lonely path.
12. Combine Top-Down & Bottom-Up Change
For effective transformation of attitudes, culture, and behavior, implement both grassroots, bottom-up efforts (individual skills training) and top-down political and organizational changes simultaneously.
13. Focus on Skills for Resilience
Shift from merely discussing stress and trauma to providing actionable skills training in resilience, enabling individuals to navigate traumatic situations, regulate stress, and achieve post-traumatic growth.
14. Individual Power in Systemic Issues
Recognize that individual changes, such as a police officer’s shift in awareness and compassion through mindfulness, can radically alter encounters and, over time, ‘infect’ teams and cultures, making a significant difference even within challenging systems.
15. Integrate Warrior Ethos with Compassion
Cultivate a ‘fierce compassion’ that allows one to be a ‘badass warrior’ (someone who runs to crisis and acts meaningfully without creating more harm) without being unkind or judgmental.
7 Key Quotes
I think that we all intuitively have this meditative capacity as a human being.
Richard Goerling
You can be a badass warrior, and that could be in news media or policing or whatever profession, but you don't have to be a dick.
Richard Goerling
If I show up as the a**hole, if I show up with the attitude, with the authoritative approach to this, then what we see is a greater incidence of force response, a greater incidence of enforcement, period.
Richard Goerling
Awareness and compassion are the gateway to performance.
Richard Goerling
Parenting is this journey of realizing just how much work you have to do on your own self.
Richard Goerling
I finally have come to a place where I'm comfortable with being the weirdo that is going to talk about mindfulness and being the person in law enforcement, being the white male in law enforcement that's willing to talk about the oppression of people of color in the criminal justice system.
Richard Goerling
I see a lot of my path as a bridge. And not as the only bridge, but as a bridge to bring communities together.
Richard Goerling
2 Protocols
Modified MBSR Course for Police (Hillsboro Police Department)
Richard Goerling- Remove 'touchy-feely' elements from the standard 8-week Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) course.
- Incorporate 'grittier' content that resonates with law enforcement experiences.
- Add a focus on movement, including gentle yoga practices, to address physical ailments common among officers.
- Frame mindfulness training within a 'warrior ethos' concept to make it culturally relevant and acceptable to police personnel.
Intensive Immersion Mindfulness Training (Bend, Oregon)
Richard Goerling- Begin with a 4-hour training session on a Friday evening.
- Continue with a long day of training on Saturday, starting early (e.g., 7:30 AM) with meditation and including various activities.
- Conclude with another 8-9 hour day of training on Sunday, completing the intensive exposure.