Meditation, Therapy, and "Murderous Rage", Dr. Susan Pollak

Oct 23, 2019 Episode Page ↗
Overview

Dr. Susan Pollak, a psychologist and co-founder at Harvard Medical School's Center for Mindfulness and Compassion, discusses integrating meditation into psychotherapy and self-compassion for parents. She shares short, accessible practices for managing stress, shame, and everyday challenges, applicable to anyone.

At a Glance
37 Insights
1h 28m Duration
15 Topics
6 Concepts

Deep Dive Analysis

Introduction to Susan Pollak and Episode Themes

Susan's Early Meditation Experience as a Refuge

Career Path: Comparative Religion to Psychology

Addressing Scandals and Doubt in Spiritual Communities

Integrating Meditation Practices into Psychotherapy

The Concept and Common Misunderstandings of Self-Compassion

Metaphors for Approaching Difficult Inner Experiences

The Three-Step Self-Compassion Break Practice

Working with Inner Critics and the Emotion of Shame

Understanding and Managing 'Murderous Rage' in Parenting

Short, On-the-Go Mindfulness Practices and Their Impact

A Guided Practice for Finding Inner Calm Amidst Stress

Critique of 'Snowplow Parenting' and Its Effects on Resilience

Strategies for Introducing Mindfulness to Children

Mindful Approaches to Parenting Adult Children, Including Addiction

Internal Family Systems (IFS)

A school of therapy that views the psyche not as layers like an onion, but as a 'clove of garlic' with various 'parts.' These parts can be needy, hurt, or controlling, but some are also 'protectors' trying to help, even if in warped ways.

Murderous Rage (in parenting)

A term used in psychoanalytic theory to describe the intense aggressive feelings parents can experience towards their children. It's a common human response that can cause guilt but is recognized as a normal, albeit uncomfortable, part of the parenting experience.

Self-Compassion Break

A three-step practice to navigate difficult moments, developed by Kristen Neff and Chris Germer. It involves acknowledging suffering, recognizing common humanity, and offering oneself kindness, which can be adapted to personal preferences.

Equanimity

The capacity to remain calm and balanced in the face of difficult or distressing stimuli. It is considered a crucial element for mediating against burnout and compassion or empathy fatigue, allowing one to be present without being overwhelmed.

RAIN Practice

A mindfulness practice for working with difficult emotions, popularized by Michelle McDonald. RAIN stands for Recognize (what is happening), Acknowledge (its presence), Investigate (its nature), and Non-identify (with the experience, or Respond with nourishment).

Snowplow Parenting

A parenting style where parents actively remove all obstacles and difficulties from their children's paths, sometimes using unethical means. This approach, while well-intentioned, can hinder children from developing resilience and learning from their own struggles.

?
Why do allegedly enlightened spiritual teachers sometimes behave badly?

There's no simple answer, but possible reasons include unmet needs, personal wounds, the corrupting influence of absolute power, and the inherent difficulty of extinguishing greed, hatred, and delusion, even after decades of practice.

?
How can meditation and psychotherapy be combined effectively?

Meditation can be integrated into therapy by teaching patients practices like breathing, settling, or grounding to shift conversations and help them cope with depression or anxiety. Alternatively, individuals can engage in both therapy and meditation separately to maintain clarity and address personal issues.

?
What is 'self-compassion' and why is it often misunderstood?

Self-compassion is essentially not being a jerk to yourself, not beating yourself up, and extending kindness to yourself. It's often misunderstood as being 'ooey-gooey' or making people 'wimps,' but it's a powerful prerequisite for sustainable outward-facing compassion and greater effectiveness.

?
How can parents deal with 'murderous rage' towards their children?

This common human experience can be addressed through a practice of grounding, noticing where the rage manifests in the body, observing it rise and fall like surfing an urge, and then returning to present sensations, reminding oneself 'that was then, this is now' to break cycles of rumination.

?
Can short, on-the-go mindfulness practices be as impactful as longer formal sessions?

New research, such as that by Jud Brewer, suggests that 'stealth mindfulness' or 'compassion-to-go' (e.g., mindful dishwashing, walking, or RAIN practice) can have a significant positive impact, though the full extent of its difference is still being studied.

?
How can parents introduce mindfulness to their children?

It's best to make it fun and accessible, perhaps through 'silly walks' to focus on body sensations, observing clouds like thoughts, or listening to and counting sounds. It may also be more effective if someone other than the parent teaches it, as children often reflexively reject parental suggestions.

?
How can parents mindfully navigate challenges with adult children, especially regarding bad decisions or addiction?

Parents should recognize that adult children's brains are still developing and that they cannot control their children's happiness or unhappiness. The key is to boost one's own equanimity and capacity to remain calm in difficult situations, using phrases like 'all beings are on their own journey' or 'I care for you, but I can't control your happiness.' For addiction, specific programs like those by Judson Brewer or Jess Morey are recommended.

1. Practice the Self-Compassion Break

When facing a difficult situation, take a self-compassion break by: 1) Acknowledging ’this is a tough moment,’ 2) Recognizing ’this is the human condition’ (common humanity), and 3) Offering yourself kindness (e.g., ‘May I be kind to myself?’ or ‘What do I need right now?’).

2. Tame Your Inner Critic

Actively tell your inner critic to ‘chill out’ or ’take a break’ to reduce self-blame and harsh internal dialogue.

3. Invite Difficult Emotions to Tea

Instead of fighting or yelling at difficult inner experiences, approach them with kindness and curiosity, as if inviting them to tea.

4. Practice ‘Murderous Rage’ Surfing

When experiencing intense anger, sit comfortably, ground yourself with breath, locate the sensation in your body, acknowledge ’this is what it feels like,’ and then ‘surf’ the urge by letting it rise and fall, knowing no feeling lasts more than 30 seconds.

5. Acknowledge Inner Protector Parts

Identify and name your inner ‘protector parts’ (e.g., inner critic), acknowledge their past attempts to help, and then gently tell them they can stand down or take a break, as their methods may no longer be useful.

6. Use Self-Compassion for Shame

Apply self-compassion practices to work effectively with shame by acknowledging the shamed parts of yourself and listening to the stories they have to tell, understanding shame’s deep social roots.

7. Always Resume Meditation Practice

If you’ve missed your meditation practice or had a difficult day, remember that you can always start again and return to the practice.

8. View Meditation as Rest

Approach meditation as a refuge where you can relax and rest, rather than feeling the need to ‘work hard’ at it.

9. Meditate to Metabolize Anxiety

Engage in meditation, even for a significant duration like 40 minutes, to help process and metabolize anxiety, leading to a calmer state.

10. Accept Reality, Adapt to What Is

Practice accepting situations as they are, rather than how you wish them to be, by ‘playing the ball where the monkey drops it’ and adapting to present circumstances.

11. Develop Short Mindfulness Practices

Create or find short (3-5 minute) mindfulness practices that you can use to get back on track during difficult moments, such as after a fight or when feeling sleep-deprived.

12. Be 10% Kinder to Self

Reframe self-compassion as simply being 10% kinder to yourself, avoiding self-criticism and harsh self-judgment.

13. Distance from Inner Critic

Create mental distance from your inner critic by observing its thoughts without fully identifying with them, recognizing that they are not the whole truth of who you are.

14. Personalize Self-Compassion Phrases

Adapt self-compassion phrases to resonate with you personally, asking ‘What do I need right now?’ or ‘What would help right now?’ instead of using generic or ‘ooey-gooey’ language.

15. Use Simple Acceptance Phrases

When struggling, use simple, direct phrases like ‘It’s okay,’ ‘This is it,’ or ‘This sucks, but I can handle it’ to acknowledge the moment without judgment.

16. Offer Inner Support to Yourself

Internally offer words of support to yourself, such as ‘I’m listening,’ ‘I’m here for you,’ or ‘I have your back,’ to acknowledge and comfort inner parts that feel anxious or worried.

17. Question Inner Parts’ Age

When an inner ‘protector part’ takes over, ask it, ‘How old do you think I am?’ to recognize if its protective strategies are outdated and no longer serve your current adult self.

18. Use ‘That Was Then, This Is Now’

When caught in past experiences of shame or anger, use the mantra ‘That was then, this is now’ to break the cycle of rumination and bring yourself back to the present moment.

19. Prioritize Self-Care After Stress

After stressful events like a child’s tantrum, prioritize self-care activities (e.g., taking a walk, having a drink) to recover and manage your own distress.

20. Include Self in Circle of Care

Extend the same care and consideration you give to others (family, coworkers) to yourself, acknowledging that your own needs are valid and count.

21. Practice Stealth Mindfulness Daily

Integrate small, on-the-go moments of mindfulness into daily activities like washing dishes, changing diapers, or walking, as these ‘stealth practices’ can have a significant impact.

22. Utilize the RAIN Practice

When facing difficult emotions, use the RAIN practice: Recognize what is happening, Acknowledge it, Investigate the sensations, and then Non-identify with it or Nourish yourself with kindness.

23. Find Stillness in Stormy Times

Use the ‘still place in a stormy sea’ visualization to combat burnout: imagine dropping below life’s stressful ‘waves’ to a calm, quiet place where you can rest and feel rejuvenated.

24. Allow Kids to Face Obstacles

Resist ‘snowplow parenting’ by allowing children to encounter and navigate their own obstacles, as these struggles are crucial for developing resilience and learning.

25. Model Mindfulness for Children

Instead of lecturing or evangelizing about mindfulness, model the practice yourself, allowing children to observe and normalize it in their own lives.

26. Introduce Mindfulness Playfully to Kids

When introducing mindfulness to children, make it fun and engaging rather than expecting them to sit quietly with eyes closed, as this approach is more effective for kids.

27. Use Silly Walks for Kids’ Body Awareness

Encourage children to do ‘silly walks’ (e.g., backwards, on all fours) and then guide them to notice the sensations in their bodies, using this playful activity to build body awareness and mindfulness.

28. Clouds as Thoughts Metaphor for Kids

Sit with children outdoors, observe clouds moving across the sky, and gently explain that these changing clouds are like thoughts and emotions in our minds, constantly in flux.

29. Practice Sound Awareness with Kids

Engage children in mindfulness by having them listen to sounds, counting or naming them, to encourage focused attention on their environment.

30. Outsource Kids’ Mindfulness Instruction

Consider having someone other than a parent teach mindfulness to children, as kids are often wired to reject suggestions from their parents, making an external teacher potentially more effective.

31. Teach & Use Soothing Touch

Teach children (e.g., using a stuffed animal) to identify where they need soothing touch when upset, and apply it to yourself or others during distress, such as placing a hand on the chest.

32. Understand Adult Children’s Brains

Recognize that adult children, especially into their mid-to-late 20s, still have developing brains, which can explain why they may make questionable decisions.

33. Cultivate Equanimity for Adult Children

Boost your own equanimity through meditation to increase your capacity to remain calm and accepting when adult children make difficult or frustrating decisions.

34. Use Equanimity Phrases for Adult Children

When dealing with adult children’s decisions, use equanimity phrases such as ‘All beings are on their own journey,’ ‘I care for you, but I can’t control your happiness,’ or ‘May I accept this just as it is.’

35. Seek Addiction Support Programs

If your adult child is struggling with addiction, seek out excellent programs designed to help individuals and families work through these challenges.

36. Tailor Practices to Individual Needs

When engaging with mindfulness or therapy, identify specific practices (e.g., equanimity, loving kindness, concentration) that best fit your current struggles or emotional state.

37. Use Dark Mode for Screens

Enable dark mode on your meditation app and phone to reduce screen brightness, making evening or early morning meditation more soothing for your eyes.

You can't stop the waves, but you can learn to surf.

Swami Satchanananda

The bigger the front, the bigger the back.

Rabbi's grandmother (quoted by Susan Pollak)

I'm not perfect, but there are parts of me that are excellent.

Susan Pollak

Mindfulness is the foundation of the house. And then we build on that.

Jon Kabat-Zinn (quoted by Susan Pollak)

What would you say to your best friend who's having a similar situation? Would you say, oh, you are so stupid. You idiot. You keep screwing up your life. What is wrong with you? No.

Susan Pollak

It's mildly annoying but deeply useful.

Dan Harris

The hardest part of parenting is letting your kids make their own mistakes.

Dan Harris's father (quoted by Dan Harris)

Self-Compassion Break

Susan Pollak (referencing Kristen Neff and Chris Germer)
  1. Acknowledge that this is a difficult moment (e.g., 'This is a moment of suffering,' 'This is a tough moment,' 'This hurts,' 'This is uncomfortable').
  2. Recognize common humanity, realizing that you are not alone in this experience (e.g., 'This is the human condition,' 'I'm not alone with this').
  3. Offer yourself kindness, such as a soothing touch (hand on heart/belly) or a kind phrase (e.g., 'May I be kind to myself,' 'What do I need right now?').

Murderous Rage Practice

Susan Pollak
  1. Sit comfortably, take a deep breath, and ground yourself, anchoring with your breath or body sensations.
  2. Notice what you're feeling and tune in to where in your body you're experiencing the 'murderous rage' (e.g., belly, jaw, chest).
  3. If comfortable, place a hand on that area of the body.
  4. Acknowledge, 'Ah, this is what murderous rage feels like. Let me pay attention to this,' and let the feeling rise and fall, like surfing an urge.
  5. Return to center by focusing on body sensations, which are always in the present moment.
  6. Check in with how you're feeling, noting any shift towards curiosity rather than being owned by the emotion.
  7. (Optional) Use a mantra like 'That was then. This is now' to break the cycle of rumination.

Still Place in a Stormy Sea Practice (for burnout)

Susan Pollak (simplified from a Dalai Lama teaching)
  1. Sit comfortably, ground yourself by feeling your feet on the ground, and take a few breaths to be present.
  2. Visualize a beautiful, calm harbor with a boat, then imagine a sudden storm with strong winds, waves, thunder, lightning, and hail lashing the boat (and yourself within it).
  3. Imagine dropping below the stormy surface, perhaps with scuba gear, to a quiet, still place where the waves and wind are above you.
  4. Rest in this quiet place, feeling held, rejuvenated, and getting a rest, knowing the storm will pass.
  5. Tune into your body, noticing and letting go of any tension or tightness (a body scan).
  6. When ready, find movement in your arms and legs, and slowly open your eyes.
30 seconds
Duration no feeling lasts more than According to research mentioned by Susan Pollak regarding surfing an urge.
80%
Percentage of people who stop breathing while on screens Referred to as 'screen apnea,' a basic practice is to remember to breathe.