Critiquing Effective Altruism (with Michael Nielsen and Ajeya Cotra)

Aug 19, 2022 1h 38m 12 insights Episode Page ↗
Spencer Greenberg, Michael Nielsen, and Ajaya Kotra discuss effective altruism (EA), exploring its definition, intellectual project, and community. They delve into critiques regarding its demanding nature, centralized funding, and the challenge of identifying the most impactful causes, contrasting EA's approach with decentralized efforts and personal values.
Actionable Insights

1. Separate Altruism Commitment & Strategy

Distinguish between the personal decision of how much time, energy, or money to devote to altruism and the intellectual project of figuring out how to use those resources most effectively. This separation helps clarify one’s engagement with effective altruism.

2. Prioritize Impact in Career Choice

When picking a career, consider ‘impact’ as an important criterion. Evaluate how your work can contribute to doing the most good possible, aligning personal fit with altruistic goals.

3. Manage Burnout in Altruistic Work

Recognize the importance of finding a personal fit in altruistic careers and actively manage the risk of burnout. Sustaining your efforts over the long term requires balancing demanding work with personal well-being.

4. Regularly Question Career Effectiveness

Continuously question whether you are using your time in the most effective possible way and if your career’s focus makes sense. Reflect on your beliefs about long-term, big-picture questions that could inform your actions.

5. Focus on Unserved Constituencies

Direct altruistic efforts towards groups that markets structurally fail to serve, such as the global poor, animals, and future generations. These areas often present opportunities for high impact where traditional economic mechanisms fall short.

6. Frame Altruism as a Quest

Approach your altruistic efforts as a continuous quest to identify the most important thing you could do with your career or money. This mindset encourages ongoing learning and adaptation to new information.

7. Distrust Centralized Cause Prioritization

Be wary of overly centralized systems, especially those driven by money, that dictate cause prioritization. Instead, foster a decentralized approach where individuals pursue their own well-reasoned intuitions about impactful work.

8. Find Balanced Self-Pressure

Recognize that there’s a ‘Laffer curve’ for self-pressure; a non-zero amount of pushing yourself is beneficial, but too much can lead to burnout and reduced motivation. Aim for an appropriate level of tension to sustain long-term commitment.

9. Acknowledge Diverse Personal Values

Integrate and acknowledge that you have multiple personal values beyond strict utilitarianism, such as friendship or family. Understand that these values often drive behavior and contribute to a more settled sense of self, even if they don’t directly maximize global utility.

10. Use Uplift App for Mood Control

If feeling down, out of sorts, or agitated, use the Uplift app to better control your mood and relieve stress and depression. It guides users through customized cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) skills.

11. Explore ClearerThinking.org Tools

Utilize the free interactive tools and tests on clearerthinking.org, such as the rationality test or common misconceptions game, to improve critical thinking, make better decisions, and achieve goals.

12. Subscribe to One Helpful Idea

Sign up for the ‘One Helpful Idea’ email newsletter at clearerthinkingpodcast.com to receive one valuable idea in 30 seconds each week, along with new podcast episodes, essays, and event announcements.