Moment 122: The Unseen And Horrifying Knock On Effect Of Dating Apps On Our Society - Scott Galloway

Aug 11, 2023
Overview

This episode analyzes how online dating creates mating inequality, negatively impacting young men and society. It proposes solutions like enhancing economic viability, promoting physical fitness, fostering community engagement, and leveraging relationships for accountability.

At a Glance
4 Insights
12m 3s Duration
10 Topics
3 Concepts

Deep Dive Analysis

Evolution of Dating: From Traditional to Online

Technology's Impact: Winner-Take-Most in Dating

Online Dating Dynamics: Women's Filters and Male Attention Skew

Mating Inequality and 'Porsche Polygamy'

Societal Consequences of Online Dating for Men

Impact on Women and Household Formation

Addressing the Challenges for Young Men

The Importance of Physical Fitness and Guardrails

Negative Behaviors of Unmotivated Young Men

Political Ramifications of Disenfranchised Young Men

Winner-Take-Most Market

When technology enters any sector, it tends to consolidate it, leading to one or a few dominant players controlling a large share. This dynamic, applied to dating apps, creates an unhealthy distribution of attention and success, where a small percentage of individuals receive the vast majority of interest.

Gini Coefficient (Online Dating)

An economic measure of income inequality, which when applied to online dating, reveals a level of mating inequality similar to income inequality in Venezuela. This indicates a highly skewed distribution of romantic interest and attention, where a few individuals garner most of the interest.

Porsche Polygamy

A term describing the phenomenon in online dating where the top 10% of men, based on online attractiveness, receive 90% of female interest. This leads to poor behavior among the highly sought-after men and effectively shuts out the bottom 50% of men from the dating market.

?
How has dating changed over time, and what role do dating apps play now?

Historically, people met through work, friends, and school in roughly equal thirds. Now, well over 50% of relationships begin online, making dating apps the dominant method for meeting partners.

?
What happens when technology enters a sector like dating?

Technology tends to consolidate sectors into 'winner-take-most' markets, where a few dominant players or individuals capture the majority of attention or resources, creating an unhealthy dynamic.

?
What are the key criteria women use for mate selection, and how does online dating affect this?

Women primarily consider a man's ability to signal resources, intelligence, and kindness. Online dating makes it difficult to signal intelligence and kindness, leading to an overemphasis on resources and a concentration of female interest on a very small group of men.

?
How does online dating impact men of varying attractiveness levels?

Online dating is highly beneficial for the top 10% of men (who receive 90% of interest), acceptable for the top 50%, but disastrous for the bottom 50%, who are largely excluded from the dating market.

?
What are the societal dangers of a large population of 'young, broken, alone men'?

This cohort of economically and emotionally non-viable men is considered the 'most dangerous person in the world,' linked to incidents like mass shootings and radicalization, posing an existential risk to society.

?
What are the broader economic and social consequences of women out-graduating men in college?

With women graduating at double the rate of men and tending to mate socioeconomically horizontally or up, there's less household formation and lower birth rates, which can stunt an economy, as college-educated women are often not interested in men without degrees.

?
What are practical steps to help young men become more viable and integrated into society?

Solutions include providing more job opportunities, vocational training, and certifications to improve economic viability and confidence, fostering community, promoting physical fitness, and establishing 'guardrails' like stable relationships and employment to provide structure and motivation.

?
What negative behaviors are observed in unmotivated young men?

These men often seek dopamine hits from speculative trading, rely on porn instead of real-world dating, gain affirmation from angry social media posts, blame women and others, become prone to misogynistic content and conspiracy theories, and generally become 'shitty citizens.'

?
How do these disenfranchised young men influence politics?

This cohort often has disproportionate political influence because elected leaders appeal to their tribal instincts, leading to the election of politicians who stoke nationalist fears, blame immigrants, and promote conspiracy theories, further exacerbating societal divisions.

1. Prioritize Physical Fitness

Dedicate time to physical fitness to become a stronger version of yourself, as this leads to increased happiness, reduced depression, greater attractiveness, and enhanced confidence and kindness.

2. Improve Economic Viability

Pursue job opportunities, vocational programs, or higher education to become more economically viable, as this builds confidence and provides a foundation for personal growth and societal contribution.

3. Engage in Community & Social Service

Actively participate in social service or community activities to meet people, develop friendships, and foster relationships, which are essential for personal well-being and societal connection.

4. Seek Relationships for Accountability

Cultivate relationships, especially romantic ones, as they can provide crucial ‘guardrails’ and motivation, encouraging better behavior and personal responsibility, particularly for young men.

We're producing too many of what is the most dangerous person in the world, and that is a young, broken, alone man.

Scott Galloway

If you apply the Gini coefficient to online dating, it's got the same Gini coefficient as income inequality in Venezuela.

Scott Galloway

Any person under the age of 30, man or woman, should be able to walk into any room and think if shit got real, I could kill and eat everybody or outrun them, one or the other.

Scott Galloway

Young men need guardrails. They need a girlfriend, a job to tell them, no, you need to put on a shirt and get into work.

Scott Galloway

What happens when technology comes into any sector is it consolidates it. It becomes a winner-take-most market.

Scott Galloway

Men who are the top 10% in terms of attractiveness online get 90% of the interest.

Scott Galloway
A third work, a third friends, a third school
Traditional meeting places for couples How people used to meet before online dating became prevalent.
Well above 50%
Current percentage of relationships starting online The majority of relationships for younger generations begin online.
46 of 50 women express all interest to 4 men
Female interest distribution on dating apps (example) Illustrates the highly skewed distribution of attention on platforms like Tinder.
Top 10% of men get 90% of interest
Male attention distribution on dating apps Refers to men in terms of online attractiveness receiving the vast majority of female attention.
1 in 3 males under 30
Young American men without sex Has not had sex in the last 12 months in America.
2 women for every 1 man
College graduation ratio (future projection) Projected ratio of female to male college graduates in the next five years.
28%
Female representation in US elected officials Percentage of elected representatives in the US who are female.
More female than male graduates for 40 years
US college graduation trend Consistent trend in the United States over the last four decades.