#44 Barbara Coloroso: The Kids Are Worth It
Parenting expert Barbara Coloroso shares her three foundational principles for child-rearing, emphasizing raising ethical, accountable children. She details protocols for mistakes, mischief, and mayhem, and offers strategies for non-violent conflict resolution, digital literacy, and open communication about sensitive topics.
Deep Dive Analysis
18 Topic Outline
Barbara Coloroso's Background and Core Philosophy
Critique of Behavior Modification in Child-Rearing
Three Foundational Tenets for Raising Ethical Children
Distinguishing Mistakes, Mischief, and Mayhem
Restorative Practices for Addressing Harmful Actions
Navigating Sibling Conflict and Bullying
Parenting Styles: Brick Wall, Jellyfish, and Backbone
Discipline vs. Punishment: Implementing Consequences
Fostering Responsibility and Decision-Making
Alternatives to Rewards, Bribes, and Threats
Encouragement, Feedback, and Deep Caring
Effective Bedtime Routines
Responding to and Empowering Children Against Bullying
Parental Modeling, Psychological Safety, and Real-World Consequences
Alternatives to Saying 'No' and Admitting Mistakes
The 'If You Hit, You Sit' Discipline Approach
Family Meetings for Collaborative Problem-Solving
Digital Literacy, Media Violence, and Open Communication
10 Key Concepts
Inner Discipline
This refers to self-discipline developed by giving children opportunities to make choices, decisions, and mistakes, and holding them accountable. It helps them understand they have agency in their lives and that their actions matter.
Restorative Practices
A three-part approach (Restitution, Resolution, Reconciliation) for addressing mayhem or serious harm. It focuses on the perpetrator owning and fixing what they did, figuring out how to prevent recurrence, and healing with the person they harmed when the targeted individual is ready.
Brick Wall Parenting
A rigid, authoritarian parenting style characterized by 'my way or the highway' rules, using bribes, threats, rewards, and punishments to control children. This approach tends to foster rebellion or fear in children, hindering their ability to think for themselves.
Jellyfish Parenting
A permissive and inconsistent parenting style where parents avoid conflict and lack clear boundaries, often saying things like 'Oh, please, your brothers and sisters, you're supposed to love one another.' This approach fails to equip children with the tools to handle conflict effectively.
Backbone Parenting
A balanced parenting style that provides both flexibility and structure. It teaches children to handle conflict non-violently by empowering them to make choices, solve problems, and learn from consequences, while still providing necessary guidance.
Discipline vs. Punishment
Punishment is adult-oriented, imposed from without, and teaches fear or resistance. Discipline, rooted in the Latin 'to give life to learning,' is done *with* the child, using reasonable, simple, valuable, and practical (RSVP) consequences to foster learning and self-correction.
Teasing vs. Taunting
Teasing is lighthearted, mutual, and involves laughing *with* someone, stopping if distress is shown. Taunting is one-sided, involves laughing *at* someone, often uses bigoted comments disguised as jokes, and continues even when the other person is distressed.
Tattling vs. Telling
Tattling is reporting something to get someone *in* trouble for minor infractions. Telling (or reporting) is sharing information to get someone *out of* trouble, especially when someone is being hurt or is in danger.
Deep Caring
More than just liking someone, deep caring is the 'must to relieve somebody else's suffering and wishing them well.' It is the antithesis of mean and cruel behavior and should be the fundamental basis for all rules and interactions.
Three Gates for Communication
A principle for communication, especially digital, where words must pass three tests before being spoken or sent: Is it true? Is it necessary? Is it kind? If it fails any of these, it should not be communicated.
12 Questions Answered
Her tenets are: kids are worth it (our time, energy, and resources), don't treat kids in a way you wouldn't want to be treated, and if a method works, it must leave both your dignity and the child's dignity intact.
Parents should provide opportunities for children to make choices and decisions, hold them accountable for mistakes, mischief, or mayhem, and allow them to experience agency in their lives, understanding that their actions have consequences.
A mistake is an unintentional act (e.g., accidentally marking a wall), mischief is intentional but less severe wrongdoing (e.g., tic-tac-toe on a wall), and mayhem is a harmful, mean, or cruel act (e.g., writing a gross term about another child).
Parents should teach non-violent conflict resolution by removing the source of conflict (e.g., turning off the TV) and requiring the children to develop a mutually agreeable plan to resolve their issue, intervening only if the plan involves harm.
Instead of these, children need encouragement, specific feedback (compliments, comments, and constructive criticism), a sense of deep caring, and appropriate discipline that focuses on learning rather than control.
Parents should stop everything, sit down, and listen softly and attentively, asking 'Talk to me about it.' They should empower the child and assure them that their report will be handled to ensure their safety without fear of retaliation.
Parents can teach children to stand strong, roll their shoulders around and down, and use an assertive voice to label the behavior as 'mean' or 'cruel' (calling the deed, not the kid), then remove themselves from the situation.
Children need to hear: 'I believe in you,' 'I trust in you,' 'I know you can handle it,' 'You're listened to,' 'You're cared for,' and 'You're very important to me.'
Parents should intervene if a situation is life-threatening, morally threatening, or unhealthy. Otherwise, they should allow children to experience the consequences of their choices, offering guidance and wisdom without being overly controlling.
Parents can simply say, 'I blew it' or 'I lost it,' take a moment to calm down, and then come up with a more sensible plan. This models self-correction and vulnerability, showing children that it's okay to make mistakes and learn from them.
Parents should start young by using proper anatomical terms, be open to questions, and discuss sexuality as an integral part of being, setting age-appropriate limits and boundaries, and teaching digital safety regarding online content.
Tattling is about getting someone *in* trouble, often for minor issues. Telling (or reporting) is about getting someone *out of* trouble, especially when someone is being hurt or is in danger.
46 Actionable Insights
1. Prioritize Core Issues
Let go of non-critical matters by asking if something is life-threatening, morally-threatening, or unhealthy. If not, allow it to pass, focusing energy on truly significant concerns.
2. Treat Others as You Wish
Apply the golden rule to children: never treat a child in a way you would not want to be treated yourself. This fosters respect and models ethical behavior.
3. Uphold Mutual Dignity
Ensure that any disciplinary action or interaction leaves both your dignity and the child’s dignity intact. Avoid actions that destroy a child’s sense of self-worth or harm them.
4. Foster Agency and Accountability
Provide children with opportunities to make choices, decisions, and mistakes, then hold them accountable for their actions. This helps them understand that what they do matters and they have agency in their lives.
5. Gradually Increase Responsibility
Continuously increase age- and ability-appropriate responsibilities and decision-making opportunities for children, while gradually decreasing limits and boundaries. The goal is for them to be fully responsible for their own behavior and choices by the time they leave home.
6. Teach Self-Discipline Framework
Implement a clear framework for responding to mistakes, mischief, and mayhem: for mistakes, ‘own it, fix it, learn from it, move on’; for mischief, show them what they did wrong, give ownership, and provide solutions; for mayhem (bullying), use restorative practices (restitution, resolution, reconciliation).
7. Demand Action, Not Apologies
Instead of demanding an apology, require the child to own what they did and fix it. Genuine remorse is shown through action, not just words, especially when apologies can be insincere.
8. Ensure Restorative Remorse
When engaging in restorative practices for mayhem, ensure the child who caused harm shows genuine remorse. If they smirk or don’t take it seriously, stop the process and revisit it later, as true healing cannot occur without it.
9. Empower Targeted Children
Provide children who are targeted with tools for standing up and speaking out for themselves. This includes teaching assertive language and physical stances, and encouraging them to remove themselves from uncomfortable situations.
10. Address Sibling Bullying Seriously
Recognize and address sibling bullying using the ’three R’s’ (restitution, resolution, reconciliation) framework. Do not dismiss it as normal conflict, as it can have long-term negative impacts on the targeted child.
11. Teach Personal Control & Influence
Educate children on personal boundaries and influence by explaining they control half of an interaction, influence 100% of it, and ’no’ is a complete sentence. This empowers them in conflict and personal relationships.
12. Distinguish Telling from Tattling
Teach children the difference between tattling (getting someone in trouble) and telling/reporting (getting someone out of trouble or stopping harm). Reinforce that reporting harm is courageous and necessary.
13. Prioritize Safety in Bullying
When addressing bullying, prioritize keeping the targeted child and any witnesses safe, even if it means delaying direct confrontation with the bully. Gather information discreetly to intervene effectively without risking further harm to the victim.
14. Model Assertive Communication
Demonstrate assertive communication by directly confronting bigoted or inappropriate comments, even from family members. Explain to your children why you are doing so, showing them how to stand up for values when it’s difficult.
15. Consequences: RSVP Criteria
Ensure consequences are RSVP: Reasonable, Simple, Valuable (teaching a lesson), and Practical. This makes discipline effective and focused on learning rather than punishment.
16. Let Go of Parental Efficiency
Prioritize a child’s learning and development over parental efficiency. Allow children to take longer to complete tasks like making lunch or doing laundry, understanding that these are crucial steps toward independence.
17. Start Chores Early for Independence
Teach children age-appropriate chores from a young age and hold them accountable. The goal is for them to be capable of managing a household and their own needs by the time they leave home.
18. It’s Never Too Late
If you feel you’ve ‘done it all wrong’ with older children, affirm that it’s never too late to start teaching responsibility. Initiate conversations about increasing their responsibilities and reducing limits, working together towards their independence.
19. Offer Safe Exit Strategy
Establish a ’no questions asked’ policy where children can call you anytime, anywhere, if they feel uncomfortable or need to leave a situation. This provides a safe way out without fear of judgment or punishment.
20. Use Alternatives to ‘No’
Instead of always saying ’no,’ use alternatives like ‘yes, later,’ ‘give me a minute,’ or ‘convince me.’ This encourages children to think, negotiate, and understand reasoning, reserving ’no’ for truly critical situations.
21. Explain ‘No’ with Reasons
When you must say ’no’ to a significant request (e.g., staying out all night), provide clear, impactful reasons related to safety, such as ‘sex, jail, drugs, and personal safety.’ This helps them understand the risks and your rationale.
22. Allow Blame for Protection
Give children permission to use you as an excuse (e.g., ‘Mom won’t let me’). This provides them with a way to save face and avoid peer pressure in uncomfortable or risky situations without having to directly refuse.
23. Admit Parental Mistakes
When you make a mistake or react poorly, admit it to your children by saying, ‘I blew it.’ Take a moment to calm down, reset, and involve them in finding a sensible solution, modeling vulnerability and problem-solving.
24. Define Time Out’s Purpose
Use time out specifically for calming down and figuring out how to fix a wrong action, not as a blanket punishment. Offer choices for where to calm down (e.g., ‘rocker room or on my lap’) to help them regain control.
25. Problem-Solve in Family Meetings
Hold family meetings to address issues with a clear structure: ‘You’ve got a problem, what’s your plan?’ This empowers children to actively participate in finding solutions to family challenges, from chores to holiday plans.
26. Evolve Parental Role
Understand that your role shifts from parent during formative years to mentor and guide during adolescence, and eventually to a good friend in adulthood. Adapt your approach to meet their developmental needs.
27. Provide Six Critical Life Messages
Regularly convey these messages to children: ‘I believe in you, I trust in you, I know you can handle it, you’re listened to, you’re cared for, you’re very important to me.’ This builds psychological safety and self-worth.
28. Encourage, Don’t Just Praise
Focus on encouragement, which can happen anytime, especially when a child struggles, rather than just praise, which is judgmental and only occurs after a deed is done perfectly. Encouragement builds resilience.
29. Give Specific Deed-Based Feedback
When complimenting, ‘stroke the deed, not the kid.’ Be specific about the action and its positive impact (e.g., ‘Thank you for walking the dog; he’s so happy’). This affirms their agency and teaches cause-and-effect.
30. Use Green Pen for Corrections
In an educational context, use a ‘green pen’ to mark correct answers and instruct children to fix the incorrect ones. This conveys belief in their ability to learn and improve, rather than highlighting failure.
31. Invite Dialogue, Not Lecture
When children share achievements or struggles, respond with ‘Talk to me about it. Tell me about it.’ This open-ended invitation encourages them to share their experiences and feelings, fostering deeper communication.
32. Cultivate Gift Utilization
Teach children that if they have a gift, they have an obligation to use it for the benefit of others. Connect their talents to opportunities for service or collaboration, rather than just personal achievement.
33. Leverage Unique Strengths
Identify and highlight children’s unique strengths, especially those with learning disabilities or impulsive tendencies. Create opportunities for them to shine and use these traits constructively, like an impulsive child becoming a lifeguard.
34. Start Digital Literacy Early
Begin teaching children about being digitally savvy, civil, and safe around age five, even if they don’t own a device. They will encounter digital tools through friends, so early education is crucial.
35. Apply ‘Three Gates’ to Communication
Teach children (and model yourself) to filter all communication, online and offline, through three gates: Is it true? Is it necessary? Is it kind? If it doesn’t pass all three, do not send or say it.
36. Trust but Verify Passwords
For early teens, maintain a policy of ’trust but verify’ regarding digital safety, including knowing their passwords. This balance of trust and oversight helps protect them from online dangers.
37. Utilize Digital Safety Resources
Actively use resources like commonsensemedia.org and stopcyberbullying.org to stay informed about the latest apps, games, and online safety concerns, and to access expert-developed handouts for parents and educators.
38. Discuss Online Dangers Age-Appropriately
Have age- and ability-appropriate conversations with children about real-world online dangers, such as predators and blackmail, using examples like the Amanda Todd case. This prepares them for potential threats.
39. Demand Tech Company Accountability
Advocate and demand that tech companies developing digital tools invest resources to help keep children safe online, as parents and educators cannot do it alone.
40. Use Proper Anatomical Terms
From a very young age, teach children the proper anatomical terms for their bodies. This normalizes conversations about sexuality and reduces the likelihood of using derogatory terms later on.
41. Teach Teasing vs. Taunting
Around age five, teach children the clear distinction between teasing (mutual, lighthearted, benign) and taunting (one-sided, intended to harm, bigoted). This helps them identify and respond to bullying behavior.
42. Teach Flirting vs. Sexual Bullying
By fourth grade, educate children on the difference between healthy flirting (normal, natural, mutual) and sexual bullying (harmful, one-sided, non-consensual). This provides crucial social-sexual literacy.
43. Respond Calmly to Sexual Questions
When children ask questions about sexuality, respond calmly and openly, finding out what they are truly asking. If they use a derogatory sexual term, stop it immediately, as it is mean and cruel.
44. Prepare for Puberty Proactively
Be proactive in preparing children for puberty, utilizing community resources like hospital sessions for parents and children. Have sanitary packs ready for girls and be open to discussing body changes as they occur.
45. Focus on Life Lessons, Not Oversharing
When discussing drugs, sex, or past mistakes, focus on imparting life lessons rather than oversharing your own past wrongdoings. Some experiences are best left unshared, especially if they don’t serve a constructive purpose.
46. Affirm Unconditional Love
Consistently let your children know that you love them, you are there for them, and you accept them for who they are, regardless of their identity or choices. This builds a foundation of security and trust.
10 Key Quotes
If it's not life-threatening, morally-threatening, or unhealthy, let it go.
Barbara Coloroso
Praise dependent, reward dependent children make wonderful henchmen for bullies.
Barbara Coloroso
Conflict is inevitable. Violence is not.
Liz Osher
Those who seek revenge had best dig two graves because it's going to eat you up too.
Barbara Coloroso
Discipline is not something we do to a child. It's something we do with the child.
Barbara Coloroso
Old is never an excuse for bigotry and intolerance.
Barbara Coloroso
Trust, but verify.
Ronald Reagan
I don't care where a kid comes from... Any kid walking through those doors, it's a kid. And they need those six critical life messages.
Barbara Coloroso
Violence in our homes, I don't care, maybe it's the way we treat one another. It isn't just the online, but how do we speak to one another in our homes as adults?
Barbara Coloroso
Kids are worth it. They are worth our time, our energy, our resources to help them be all they can be because that's what matters.
Barbara Coloroso
6 Protocols
Addressing Mistakes (Simple Formula)
Barbara Coloroso- Own it.
- Fix it.
- Learn from it.
- Move on.
Addressing Mayhem (Restorative Practices)
Barbara Coloroso- Restitution: Own and fix what you did (e.g., scrubbing off graffiti, sending a message to delete online content).
- Resolution: Figure out how to keep it from happening again (e.g., temporary restrictions on computer use, changing classes, learning self-control tools).
- Reconciliation: Find a way to heal with the person you've truly harmed, when the targeted person is ready (e.g., admitting the act, offering an invitation, respecting their boundaries).
Handling Sibling Conflict (Backbone Parent Approach)
Barbara Coloroso- Take away the source of conflict (e.g., turn off the TV).
- State that they are fighting.
- Inform them they can resume the activity as soon as they both have a plan.
- Intervene only if a plan involves brute force or intimidation.
- Teach the younger child negotiation lines if they are being taken advantage of.
Responding to Hitting ('If You Hit, You Sit')
Barbara Coloroso- State clearly: 'It's all right to be angry. It's not all right to hit your brother.'
- Offer choices for time out: 'You can sit in your rocker room or on my lap.'
- Wait for the child to calm down.
- Engage in the 'Three R's' (Restitution, Resolution, Reconciliation) to address the hitting.
Three Alternatives to Saying 'No'
Barbara Coloroso- Say 'Yes, later.' (e.g., for a cookie, implying it's just a short delay).
- Say 'Give me a minute.' (to allow yourself time to think or gather information).
- Say 'Convince me.' (to empower the child to articulate their reasons and make their case).
Three Gates for Digital Communication
Barbara Coloroso- Is it true?
- Is it necessary?
- Is it kind?
- If it won't pass through all three gates, do not push send.