#50 Josh Wolfe: Inventing the Future
Josh Wolfe, co-founder of Lux Capital, discusses finding unexplored ideas, distinguishing real entrepreneurs from fakes, and his unique information processing and decision-making frameworks. He also shares insights on parenting and the future of technology.
Deep Dive Analysis
15 Topic Outline
Introduction to Lux Capital's Investment Philosophy
Distinguishing Real Entrepreneurs from Imposters
Identifying Patterns of Success and Failure in Leaders
The Impact of Parenting on Patience and Leadership
Embracing Randomness and Optionality in Life and Investing
Josh Wolfe's Framework for Information Processing
Deep Dive: Unearthing Unexplored Ideas (Nuclear Waste Example)
Future Technological Trends: Half-Life of Intimacy
Future Technological Trends: Generative Design
The Influence of Office Environment and Internal Culture
Lux Capital's Investment Decision-Making Process
Navigating Market Dynamics and Staying Price Disciplined
Lessons Learned from Working with Bill Gates
Personal Reflections on Parenting and Critical Thinking
Shared Love for Old-School Rap Music
7 Key Concepts
Randomness and Optionality
This concept suggests that many life events, both good and bad, are largely outside of one's control. The approach is to maximize potential opportunities that arise from this randomness as cheaply as possible, staying humble to the significant role of luck.
100-0-100 Framework
This framework describes a specific probability distribution for venture investing: 100% certainty that Lux will invest in cutting-edge areas, 0% certainty of what those specific areas will be, and 100% certainty of where they will find those opportunities (at the edge of their existing portfolio companies).
Fitzgerald, Twain, Schopenhauer Framework
This is a framework for information processing. Fitzgerald refers to holding two opposing ideas simultaneously; Twain refers to questioning what one knows for sure that 'just ain't so' (informational surprise); and Schopenhauer refers to genius hitting targets nobody else can see (asymmetric information).
Directional Arrows of Progress
These are undeniable, universal principles or trends across segments, sectors, and industries that move in a certain way regardless of specific actors or companies. Examples include increasing energy density per unit of raw material or technology becoming more intimate and invisible.
Half-life of Technology Intimacy
This trend describes how human interaction with computers has become progressively more intimate over time. It moves from large, distant machines to personal desktops, then laptops, then pocket-sized phones, then wearables, and eventually to invisible, integrated technologies.
Generative Design
A computational approach to creating objects and structures by telling a computer to find the optimal design for a given material and constraints. The resulting designs often mimic nature's amorphous, organic, yet mathematically precise forms, differing from traditional rectilinear human engineering.
Unum Lux
This internal Lux Capital mantra means 'one Lux' and signifies a culture of collective responsibility and collaboration. It emphasizes that both successes and failures are shared across the entire team and portfolio, encouraging partners to work on each other's companies.
8 Questions Answered
Lux Capital primarily funds scientific entrepreneurs whose work is typically peer-reviewed, patented, and replicable. They focus on asking the fundamental question: 'Does it work?' to ensure the technology is real and not just a hypothesis.
They identify what everyone else is looking at and then seek out what people are not looking at. This often involves finding asymmetrically distributed scientists or entrepreneurs with unique insights before they become widely known.
A key pattern is great storytelling ability, which allows them to recruit talent, persuade investors, and sell a vision. This skill taps into human aspirations, virtues, and desires, making them highly influential.
Clues include a CEO doing all the talking in a presentation, speaking for their team members, or wanting to be involved in every decision. This behavior might indicate a lack of trust in their hires or an attempt to control information.
He constantly explores and ingests vast amounts of information from diverse sources, looking for 'informational surprise' in what others deem less important or overlook. This broad intake allows him to connect disparate pieces of information and identify new opportunities.
He encourages them to question everything, often responding to their questions with 'what do you think?' He also uses real-world examples of 'dumb things people do' from news stories to discuss consequences, peer pressure, and learning from others' mistakes.
A champion partner presents a thesis, the team populates questions, and the entrepreneur prepares to address them. After the presentation, the team votes (invest, lead, more work, participate, pass), and if there's too much consensus, they actively seek a 'red corner' devil's advocate to identify potential flaws.
They foster an 'internally collaborative, externally competitive' culture (unum lux) where partners recap meetings and share tidbits via email and Slack. This ensures institutional knowledge is shared and leveraged across the team to support all portfolio companies.
55 Actionable Insights
1. Prioritize Human Psychology
Focus on understanding human nature and psychology, as it accounts for the majority of successes and problems in ventures, requiring an ‘armchair psychologist’ approach to diagnose team effectiveness and leadership issues.
2. Adopt a Stoic Mindset
Cultivate a Stoic mindset by focusing your energy and attention only on the things that truly matter and are within your control, rather than worrying about external factors.
3. Proactively Imagine Failure
Combat optimism bias by proactively imagining every possible way a venture could fail, then allocate time, talent, and money to prevent those anticipated negative outcomes.
4. Employ Irrefutable Logic
When making arguments or negotiating, strive to identify the objective truth and present logic that is so clear and irrefutable that others cannot disagree, leading to more effective outcomes.
5. Use “Hall of Heroes” Models
Cultivate a ‘Hall of Heroes’ – a pantheon of individuals whose decision-making you admire – and invoke their perspective by asking ‘What would X do?’ in challenging situations, also inverting for ‘bad actors.’
6. Challenge Certainties and Predictions
Actively question what everyone ‘knows for sure’ and linear predictions, looking for ‘informational surprise’ where widely accepted trends might suddenly reverse, leading to significant shocks.
7. Seek Overlooked Opportunities
First, understand what everyone else is focusing on, then actively seek out the ‘white space’ – areas or ideas that others are not looking at – to find unique opportunities.
8. Discern Universal Progress Trends
Identify ‘directional arrows of progress’ – undeniable, universal principles or trends that indicate a clear direction of technological or societal advancement, as these trends are likely to continue regardless of individual actors.
9. Acknowledge Luck and Randomness
Be humble about the amount of luck in your pursuits to open yourself to randomness and optionality, then maximize these opportunities as cheaply as possible.
10. Maximize Randomness and Optionality
Actively seek out and leverage chance meetings and unexpected circumstances, as many significant life and business opportunities arise from unpredictable events.
11. Systematically Learn New Domains
To master a new domain, combine voracious reading of scientific papers and journals with extensive networking, talking to 20-30 experts weekly, triangulating information, and iteratively refining your understanding and narrative to build credibility and recruit talent.
12. Ask “What Sucks?” for Innovation
Consistently ask ‘What sucks?’ about existing products, processes, or situations, as identifying pain points and inefficiencies is a powerful way to uncover opportunities for innovation and improvement.
13. Identify Contrarian Visionaries
Look for individuals who possess irreverence and a slight arrogance, holding a strong vision of how the world ought to look and disagreeing with consensus, then support them.
14. Prioritize Functionality Validation
When evaluating a technology or company, always ask the fundamental question: ‘Does it work?’ to ensure the core offering is functional and not based on unsupported claims.
15. Kill Risk to Create Value
View risk and value as interchangeable; actively identify and ‘kill’ risks in a project or venture, as each risk eliminated creates subsequent value and reduces the required return for future investors.
16. Cultivate Collaborative Culture
Build a culture that is internally collaborative, emphasizing information sharing among team members, while maintaining an externally competitive stance against rivals.
17. Be Direct in Feedback
Adopt a blunt and direct communication style for difficult conversations, ensuring feedback is focused on improving the situation or firm, not on personal attacks, and expect the same in return.
18. Solicit Bad News Proactively
Proactively ask for bad news from partners and team members, emphasizing that this is where you can truly help and collaborate, rather than just celebrating successes.
19. Be Wary of Unanimous Consensus
Be cautious when there is 100% consensus on a decision, as high confidence and complete agreement can be a signal that something important has been overlooked.
20. Designate a Devil’s Advocate
For critical decisions, intentionally designate a ‘red corner’ or devil’s advocate to proactively identify all potential reasons why a plan might fail and what could go wrong.
21. Record Decision Judgments
Systematically record individual judgments, perceptions, and observations for each decision to combat selective memory, refine future judgment, and encourage more nuanced rather than absolute viewpoints.
22. Identify Knowable Information
When evaluating dissenting opinions, focus on identifying what information is ‘knowable’ and verifiable through diligence, then actively seek out that information to reduce uncertainty or confirm biases.
23. Maintain Price Discipline
Prioritize long-term financial discipline over chasing every opportunity, being willing to forgo a deal if the price is too high, to protect capital and maintain a consistent investment philosophy.
24. Distill to the Core Issue
Practice distilling complex issues to their most critical 10%, absorbing all information, taking notes, and then identifying the single most important point or insight.
25. Embrace Intellectual Duality
Cultivate the ability to hold two opposing ideas in your head simultaneously without losing the capacity to function, as this is a mark of a first-rate intellect and helps navigate complex, uncertain situations.
26. Seek Unseen Opportunities
Strive to identify ‘unseen targets’ or technological secrets that nobody else has discovered, as this represents genius-level insight and is where the highest value opportunities lie.
27. Diversify Reading for Insights
Read a wide variety of news sources, including mainstream and less ‘sophisticated’ ones like USA Today, and look beyond front-page headlines to find ‘meta insights’ in less prominent sections, which may hold undervalued information.
28. Implement Diverse Information Routine
Start the day by checking emails, then Twitter, followed by skimming scientific papers and blogs for headlines, patterns, and trends, taking screenshots, and assembling collages of interesting phenomena to share with your team.
29. Focus on Undiscussed Topics
Seek out topics or areas that nobody else is talking about or thinking about, as these often represent overlooked opportunities where significant value can be found.
30. Locate Asymmetric Innovators
Identify individuals or groups who are inventing the future and possess unique, asymmetrically distributed knowledge, then build relationships and persuade them to partner with you before everybody else discovers them.
31. Identify Prodigious Scientists
Look for scientists who are highly prolific, publishing many cutting-edge papers, driven by both discovery and the desire for reputation, as these individuals often lead to significant innovation.
32. Cultivate Ambitious Postdoc Relationships
Seek out and develop relationships with aggressive, commercially-minded postdocs in the labs of famous, successful scientists, as these individuals often form a ‘fountain of opportunity and innovation.’
33. Develop Storytelling Skills
Cultivate strong storytelling ability to effectively recruit talent and attract investors, as it creates a powerful emotional connection and persuades people to join or invest in your vision.
34. Observe Delegation and Credit
During presentations, observe if a leader dominates the conversation or if they delegate and laud their team members, as the latter indicates a positive, trusting leadership style.
35. Vet Advisors for Credibility
Carefully vet the advisory board members of a company, as the presence of ‘BS scientists’ or promoters can be a ‘red flag’ signaling poor judgment from the CEO in discerning credible experts.
36. Build Credibility to Recruit
Continuously reduce ignorance and evolve your narrative through learning, as increased credibility makes it easier to recruit serious people and build an advisory board for new ventures.
37. Prioritize Active Venture Support
Actively prioritize how to help your portfolio companies by tracking their key metrics and immediate needs (e.g., specific hires), then leverage your network to provide targeted support.
38. Leverage Collective Intelligence
Systematically collect and share information across your team to create collective intelligence, allowing you to connect dots, identify competitive advantages (e.g., better lending terms), and apply insights across your portfolio.
39. Systematize Meeting Recaps
Ensure all team members consistently recap meetings, conversations, and board meeting tidbits, as this institutionalizes knowledge, creates an internal network effect, and prevents information silos.
40. Fund Milestones Incrementally
When investing, quantify how much capital is needed to achieve specific milestones within a defined timeframe, funding incrementally to de-risk the venture and adjust future investments based on progress.
41. Prepare Presenters with Questions
Before a presentation, provide the presenter with the key questions the team will ask, allowing them to prepare thoroughly and address critical concerns effectively.
42. Allow “One Per Fund” Bets
Implement a ‘one per fund’ rule where partners can push through a highly convicted investment despite team skepticism, to prevent errors of omission and foster long-term camaraderie.
43. Design Spaces for Interaction
To encourage interaction among people, design physical spaces with narrower halls and tighter structures, as constraining space can lead to more engagement than large, open atriums.
44. Foster Open Information Flow
Design office environments with open spaces and glass offices to encourage natural information flow, increase optionality for spontaneous interactions, and allow people to observe who is coming and going.
45. Utilize Peer Review
When evaluating scientific claims, rely on established filtering processes like peer review and publications to determine if a hypothesis is supported by observed, tested evidence and conclusions.
46. Balance Exploration and Exploitation
Continuously balance exploration (ingesting new information and ideas) with exploitation (applying existing knowledge), recognizing this is a constant trade-off that can lead to information anxiety but is crucial for growth.
47. Utilize Late Nights for Development
If your schedule allows, dedicate late-night hours (e.g., 11:30 PM - 1 AM) for personal reading, focused work, and consuming audiobooks at high speed to maximize learning and productivity.
48. Prioritize Attention in Parenting
Recognize that attention is the most valuable currency with children; reward positive behavior with fully engaged, eye-contact attention to provide the best positive feedback and encourage desired actions.
49. Instill Hedging and Preparedness
Teach children the principle ‘it’s better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it’ to encourage thinking about hedging, preparedness, and potential long-term consequences in various situations.
50. Foster Skeptical Thinking
Indoctrinate children with skepticism by encouraging them to question everything and reason through beliefs, rather than simply accepting dogma, by asking ‘What do you think?’ when they inquire about things like Santa Claus.
51. Learn from Others’ Mistakes
Actively review examples of people making poor decisions (e.g., from news stories) with your children, discussing the chain of events and motivations, to teach them to learn from others’ mistakes and avoid similar pitfalls.
52. Teach Balancing Conformity
Guide children to understand the balance between fitting in and standing out, recognizing when it’s appropriate to conform and when it’s crucial to assert their individuality, especially in situations like standing up for others.
53. Instill Persistence and Resilience
Consistently reinforce the value of persistence by asking ‘Does our family give up? Never,’ to instill a mindset of not giving up when facing frustration or challenges.
54. Watch for Control Freak Behavior
Be wary of leaders who are control freaks, as this can signal a lack of trust in their team, poor hiring decisions, or an attempt to hide information by controlling every decision.
55. Consider CEO Parenting Choices
When evaluating older CEOs, consider that those who chose not to have children may lack the humility gained from parenting, which can influence their management style and ability to handle irrational behavior.
5 Key Quotes
Technologies change and businesses change and markets change, but human nature is a constant.
Josh Wolfe
Talent can hit a target that nobody else can hit and genius can hit a target that nobody else can see.
Josh Wolfe
Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
Josh Wolfe
Failure comes from a failure to imagine failure.
Josh Wolfe
I would rather lose half my LPs than half my LPs' money.
Josh Wolfe
4 Protocols
Josh Wolfe's Information Processing Routine
Josh Wolfe- Check email for West Coast team updates (most productive in evenings, motivated by peers sleeping).
- Check Twitter for engaging conversations and rich content.
- Skim headlines of a handful of papers, looking for patterns and trends, taking screenshots and sharing with the team.
- Read a slew of information-rich blogs.
- At the office, flip through scientific journals (Nature, Science, Chemical & Engineering News, PNAS, NEJM) for interesting trends.
Lux Capital's Investment Decision Process
Josh Wolfe- The champion partner sends out their thesis and investment opportunity to the team.
- The team populates a series of questions (generic, specific tech, market, business model, hiring, etc.).
- The champion provides these questions to the entrepreneur to prepare for the presentation.
- After the presentation, partners immediately detail their thoughts using an internal proprietary system, indicating whether to invest, lead, need more work, participate, or pass, along with recommended investment amounts and valuation parameters.
- The team identifies a 'red corner' (devil's advocate) to highlight reasons not to do the deal, especially when there is high consensus.
- The firm prioritizes addressing dissenting comments and 'knowable' uncertainties through further diligence.
- Peter and Josh make the final decision, but will not invest without team support and are hesitant with 100% consensus.
Josh Wolfe's Deep Dive Research Process (Nuclear Industry Example)
Josh Wolfe- Start with voracious reading of scientific papers and journals to understand the problem.
- Have analysts distill information and set up calls with experts (4-6 people daily, 20-30 weekly).
- Map out connections and insights from conversations using mind-mapping software (e.g., Poplet), visually weighting the value of each contact.
- Incrementally learn from each conversation, taking the best ideas and sharing them in subsequent discussions to build credibility.
- Back-propagate information, re-evaluating contacts based on feedback (e.g., if someone is deemed 'full of it').
- Evolve the narrative and use increased credibility to recruit passionate people who deeply believe in the vision.
- Form an advisory board with famous people in the space to further build credibility and momentum.
- Continue to learn and refine understanding until confident enough to put significant capital to work and start a company.
Josh Wolfe's Approach to Teaching Skepticism to Children
Josh Wolfe- Instead of directly answering questions about mythical figures (e.g., Santa Claus), ask 'What do you think?' to encourage critical reasoning.
- Encourage children to design 'experiments' to test hypotheses (e.g., a 'Santa trap' with lasers and a birdcage).
- Introduce sayings like 'it's better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it' to teach hedging and long-term consequences.
- Discuss 'dumb things people do' from news stories (e.g., New York Post articles) to teach about human misjudgment, peer pressure, and the importance of not making those mistakes.
- Instill family norms such as 'our family does not make fun of other people' and 'our family stands up for that person' when someone is in need or being teased.