How to Break Free from Chronic Pain and Reclaim Your Life with Professor Peter O'Sullivan #472

Sep 3, 2024 Episode Page ↗
Overview

Professor Peter O'Sullivan, a Specialist Musculoskeletal Physiotherapist, challenges common myths about chronic pain, particularly lower back pain. He explains why changing the story around pain, understanding its multidimensional nature, and empowering patients with hope and movement are crucial for effective recovery.

At a Glance
45 Insights
2h 22m Duration
23 Topics
7 Concepts

Deep Dive Analysis

Introduction to Chronic Pain and Hope for Change

Impact of Chronic Back Pain on Daily Life

Personal Story: Over-Protection and Movement as Healing

Misguided Ergonomics and Lifting Advice

Healthcare's Role in Perpetuating Pain and Disability

Myth 1: Lower Back Pain is a Serious Medical Condition

Myth 2: Back Pain Deteriorates in Later Life

Cultural and Belief Systems Influence on Pain

Myth 4: Scans Always Needed to Detect Cause of Pain

The Power of Language and Messaging in Healthcare

Acute Back Pain Management: Movement and Lifestyle

Physiotherapists' Awareness of Biopsychosocial Factors

Cognitive Functional Therapy (CFT) Explained

Myth 3: Persistent Pain Always Related to Tissue Damage

Myth 5: Pain During Movement is Always Harmful

Myth 6: Lower Back Pain Caused by Poor Posture

Myth 7: Weak Core Muscles Cause Back Pain

The Interconnectedness of Core, Breath, and Pelvic Floor

Myth 8: Repeated Spinal Loading Causes Wear and Tear

Myth 9: Pain Flare-ups Require Rest

Myth 10: Strong Medications, Injections, Surgery are Necessary

The Problem of Low-Value Care and Over-Treatment

Final Thoughts: Hope and Empowerment for Pain Sufferers

Population Research

This involves studying a large group of people over time to identify factors predictive of conditions like pain. For example, the RAIN study tracked individuals from pre-birth into adulthood to understand pain development.

Qualitative Research

This approach focuses on individual stories and experiences to understand the detailed impact of conditions like back pain. It delves into how pain affects a person's life, confidence, and daily activities.

Embodied Experience with Pain

This refers to how pain manifests physically and emotionally, leading the body to go into a protective mode. This can involve tensing muscles, moving slower or stiffer, and becoming hypervigilant, which can itself create secondary pain processes.

Nocebic Thought

A negative thought or belief that can lead to adverse health outcomes or worsen symptoms. For example, believing that a round back is dangerous when lifting can create unhelpful vigilance and tension, even without actual physical harm.

Cognitive Functional Therapy (CFT)

An approach developed to manage persistent pain conditions, particularly chronic back pain. It focuses on changing the 'story' around pain by addressing unhelpful beliefs, fear, and overprotection, while empowering patients to regain confidence in movement and function through personalized programs.

Low-Value Care

Healthcare interventions that are expensive, carry risks, and offer limited or no significant benefits. Examples include unnecessary scans, spinal fusions, or opioid prescriptions for chronic back pain, which often do not improve outcomes and can lead to further harm.

High-Value Care

Healthcare that empowers and informs people, helping them understand their condition and make changes to improve their lives. It focuses on long-term benefits, self-management, and addressing multiple factors contributing to health, rather than just symptoms.

?
What is the most important message about pain that the public should know?

The most important message is hope for change. There is hope that pain, even chronic pain, can be controlled and that individuals can regain their ability to function and do the things they value in life.

?
How common is chronic pain and what is its impact?

Chronic pain affects up to 20% (one in five) people globally and is the leading cause of disability worldwide, with chronic back pain being the number one cause. It impacts daily activities, work, physical activity, and can be emotionally draining.

?
Why is back pain so debilitating compared to other injuries?

The back is central to almost every normal human function, impacting the ability to sit, stand, bend, and lift. Unlike a limb, you only have one back, and when it's painful, it disrupts everything, leading to hypervigilance and avoidance.

?
Is lower back pain usually a serious medical condition?

No, this is a myth. Only about 1% of lower back pain cases are associated with serious underlying pathology like cancer or fractures. The vast majority are not serious, and even conditions like disc prolapses often reabsorb naturally.

?
Will lower back pain become persistent and deteriorate in later life?

This is a myth. Back pain can be effectively managed at any age, and there is no evidence that it will inevitably worsen. Many age-related changes seen on scans, like disc degeneration, are normal and not necessarily the cause of pain.

?
Are scans always necessary to find the cause of lower back pain?

No, this is a myth for the majority of cases. Scans are crucial for screening serious conditions (the 1%), but for most back pain, they are not needed and can even be harmful due to misinterpretation and the negative language used in reports.

?
What is the impact of a scan report on a patient's pain and recovery?

Scan reports, especially those using terms like 'degeneration' or 'bulge,' can significantly worsen a patient's pain, disability, and mental health, even if the findings are normal age-related changes. Reassuring language, conversely, can lead to better outcomes.

?
What should someone with non-pathological acute back pain do?

After serious conditions are ruled out, the focus should be on understanding the triggers (often stress, poor sleep, inactivity), learning to relax the body, re-engaging in gentle, graduated movement, and building confidence in the body's ability to recover.

?
Does persistent lower back pain always mean there is tissue damage?

No, this is a myth. For the majority of persistent back pain, there isn't an underlying injury or tissue damage. The back is strong and designed to be loaded, and even if tissue damage occurs, the body often heals it naturally.

?
Is pain during exercise always a warning of harm to the spine?

No, this is a myth. While protection is normal for acute injuries like fractures, for most back pain, especially without a history of trauma, overprotecting and avoiding movement is unhelpful. The back needs movement to be healthy.

?
Is lower back pain caused by poor posture, and should I always keep my back straight?

This is a myth. There is no evidence that poor posture causes back pain. While it's okay to lift with a straight back, constantly holding a rigid posture or keeping the core tight is unnatural, deprives the spine of necessary movement, and can increase tension and pain.

?
Are weak core muscles the cause of lower back pain, and does a strong core protect against future pain?

This is a myth. There's no evidence that a weak core predicts back pain or that core training is a panacea. While a strong core is beneficial for certain activities, a constantly tense core is problematic, affecting breathing and potentially driving pain.

?
What is the problem with constantly sucking in your belly or keeping your core tight?

Constantly sucking in your belly creates intrapedal pressure, prevents the diaphragm from functioning effectively (leading to upper chest breathing and stress activation), and loads the pelvic floor. This can contribute to pelvic floor issues and spread tension throughout the body.

?
Are pain flare-ups always a sign of tissue damage and require rest?

No, this is a myth. Most back pain flare-ups are linked to inactivity, high stress, poor sleep, or fatigue, not tissue damage. The best response is often to move, relax, and re-engage in physical activity, rather than overprotecting and resting.

?
Are strong medications, injections, and surgery effective and necessary for lower back pain?

This is a myth. For chronic pain, opioids are not effective and carry significant risks. Spinal fusions and disc replacements often show no better outcomes than non-surgical treatments and can infuse more fear. Injections have limited, short-term benefits for specific conditions but are not a long-term solution for most back pain.

1. Cultivate Hope for Recovery

Actively cultivate hope for change and recovery from pain, believing that you can regain the ability to function and do the things you value in life.

2. Trust Body’s Healing Capacity

Understand that your body has an amazing ability to heal, with disc prolapses often reabsorbing naturally, which can reduce fear and build hope around pain.

3. Change Your Pain Narrative

Actively work on changing the story and beliefs you hold about your pain, as this is one of the most important steps to effectively tackle it.

4. Holistic Pain Management

Address both the psychological and biomechanical aspects of pain, seeking healthcare practitioners who build trust and empower you with hope, as popular strategies often fall short.

5. Embrace Movement as Healing

View movement as a healing friend, not an enemy, and actively engage in it to support your body’s recovery and overall health.

6. Prioritize Movement for Back Health

Prioritize regular movement, physical activity, and engaging in a healthy lifestyle for the health of your back, rather than adopting advice that leads to overprotection.

7. Avoid Over-Guarding and Protection

Be mindful of subconsciously tensing and guarding your back due to pain, as this overprotection can create a cycle of secondary pain, hypervigilance, and avoidance of normal activities.

8. Stop Belly Sucking & Core Bracing

Stop constantly bracing your core or ‘sucking in your belly,’ as this inhibits diaphragmatic breathing, drives your stress response, and can negatively impact your pelvic floor and overall body tension.

9. Practice Diaphragmatic Breathing

Practice diaphragmatic breathing to promote relaxation, reduce stress, and allow your core muscles to function optimally, rather than bracing and resorting to inefficient upper chest breathing.

10. Integrate Breath into Movement

Integrate diaphragmatic breathing and relaxation practices specifically into activities that cause you pain, that you avoid, or that you fear, rather than only doing them in ‘safe’ places.

11. Relax Body, Re-engage Normal Movement

Actively learn to relax your body and re-engage in normal, natural movements, challenging and breaking rigid ‘posture rules’ that may be unhelpful.

12. Trust Natural Movement Patterns

Stop consciously trying to lift or move in rigid, ‘proper’ ways for everyday tasks; instead, trust your body’s natural movement patterns, as people without pain don’t overthink these actions.

13. Vary Posture, Avoid Rigidity

Actively vary your posture throughout the day and avoid holding rigid, ‘straight back’ positions, as your spine needs movement for health.

14. Use Symptoms as Lifestyle Signals

View symptoms, including pain, as signals from your body about the current state of your life, prompting you to reflect on and change aspects of your lifestyle.

15. Manage Stress to Prevent Pain

To reduce the likelihood of pain triggers, address underlying factors like stress, tiredness, and being run down, as these significantly increase vulnerability to pain.

16. Reframe Pain Meaning

Actively reframe the meaning you assign to pain; instead of viewing it as damage, consider if it’s a sign of growth or a signal to adapt, making it less scary and more controllable.

17. Gain Control Over Pain

Seek strategies that help you understand, control, and predict your pain (e.g., relaxation, breathing, specific movements, walking), as a sense of control reduces fear and makes pain less scary.

18. Develop Pain Exacerbation Plan

Develop a personal exacerbation plan for pain flare-ups, recognizing that triggers are often stress, illness, or inactivity, and know what steps to take first.

19. Move During Pain Flare-Ups

Recognize that most pain flare-ups are linked to stress, inactivity, poor sleep, or fatigue, not new tissue damage; respond by moving, relaxing, and re-engaging in physical activity, rather than prolonged rest.

20. Graded Loading Strengthens Back

Understand that repeated, graded spinal loading makes your back, bones, discs, and muscles stronger; avoid depriving your back of load, as this is detrimental to its health.

21. Improve General Well-being for Pain

Improve your general well-being by focusing on the four pillars of health—food, movement, sleep, and relaxation—as this holistic approach can significantly alleviate back pain and other symptoms.

22. Address Subconscious Emotional Burdens

Reflect on and address any subconscious emotional burdens or unresolved stress in your life, as these can profoundly influence and perpetuate physical pain.

23. Contextualize Acute Pain Triggers

When experiencing acute pain, reflect on what was going on in your life at that time (e.g., stress, tiredness, other issues), as these factors are often more relevant than a specific injury.

24. Seek Personalized, Validating Care

Seek healthcare that prioritizes listening to your full story, validates your pain experience, and helps you understand the unique factors driving your pain to create a personalized recovery program.

25. Target Valued Activities for Recovery

Personalize your recovery program by identifying and targeting the specific activities you value and want to get back to (e.g., picking up kids, playing tennis, traveling), rather than following a generic plan.

26. Empower Self-Management of Pain

Actively seek and utilize tools and strategies that empower you to self-manage your pain condition, putting yourself in the driver’s seat of your recovery.

27. Define Good Pain Care

Define ‘good care’ as receiving a clear understanding of your condition, being empowered to make changes in your life, and getting back to activities you value.

28. Build Trust with Clinician

Build a trusting relationship with your clinician, viewing them as a coach who will guide you safely, build your skills, and help you return to valued activities.

29. Ask “What If I Do Nothing?”

Always ask your doctor, ‘What happens if I do nothing?’ to understand the natural course of your condition and avoid unnecessary interventions.

30. Leverage Pain Relief for Action

If you opt for a pain-relieving procedure, use the temporary relief as an opportunity to actively re-engage in your life and establish healthy practices to reduce the need for future interventions.

31. Back Pain Rarely Serious

Be reassured that lower back pain is rarely a serious medical condition, with serious underlying pathologies present in only about 1% of cases.

32. Manage Back Pain at Any Age

Do not believe that back pain will inevitably become persistent or worsen with age; it can be effectively managed at any age, and age-related changes on scans are often normal and not the cause of pain.

33. Normal Scan Findings Are Not Damage

Understand that terms like ‘disc degeneration’ or ‘disc bulges’ on scans are often normal, age-related changes found in many people without pain, and do not necessarily indicate damage or the cause of your pain.

34. Don’t Overprotect Non-Injury Pain

If your back pain is not linked to a specific injury, avoid protecting it, as there is no tissue damage to guard against and protection can be counterproductive.

35. ‘Poor Posture’ Not Pain Cause

Dispel the belief that ‘poor posture’ when sitting, standing, or lifting is a cause of lower back pain, as there is no evidence to support this.

36. Core Strength Not Pain Panacea

Understand that weak core muscles don’t necessarily cause back pain, and a strong core isn’t a guaranteed protector; focus on physical activity you enjoy, and avoid constantly tensing your core.

37. Movement Pain Not Always Harm

Understand that pain during exercise or movement is not always a warning of harm to your spine; avoid overprotecting if there’s no history of trauma, as this can be unhelpful.

38. Avoid Low-Value Pain Treatments

Be aware that strong medications (like opioids), injections, and surgery are often ’low-value care’ for lower back pain, carrying significant risks with limited or no long-term benefits.

39. Rethink ‘Proper’ Lifting Technique

Do not solely rely on the belief that lifting with a straight back and bent knees is inherently protective or preventative of back pain, as there is no evidence to support this ergonomic advice.

40. Beware Scan Report Language

If you receive a scan, be cautious of the language used in the report and its interpretation by healthcare professionals, as it can significantly influence your beliefs and outcomes.

41. Seek Empowering Clinician Language

Seek healthcare practitioners who use careful, empowering language when discussing your condition, as their words can profoundly influence your beliefs and recovery.

42. Seek Evolving Clinicians

Be aware that some healthcare practitioners may hold outdated beliefs about pain; seek those who are open to evolving their practice and integrating new evidence.

43. Expect Emotional Support from Physio

Expect your physiotherapist to engage with and address the emotional aspects of your pain, as it is an integral part of persistent pain experience.

44. Utilize Evolve Pain Care Academy

Visit the Evolve Pain Care Academy website (a free resource) for summarized, open-access, evidence-based information and patient stories to empower both patients and clinicians in a partnership approach to pain management.

45. Understand CFT Components

If exploring Cognitive Functional Therapy (CFT), understand its three core components: making sense of your pain, controlled exposure to feared movements, and comprehensive lifestyle changes.

Hope. Hope for change. Hope that pain is something that has an inability to be controlled. Hope that if pain limits your ability to function, your ability to do the things in life that you value, that you can't do, that there's hope to get it back.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

It's not like an ankle, you've got another one. You know, you can offload that ankle or you can modify it. But with the back, it's the center. It's kind of like the center for so many things.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

If I look at my caseload of people who I get to see, the majority of what I see, I believe, would be healthcare induced disability.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

Your language matters, what you say to a patient absolutely matters. Do not give off hand comments without thinking about it, because people take on those comments, they become their beliefs, and that then influences their behavior.

Dr. Rangan Chatterjee

The body's ability to heal is amazing. Spinal fractures heal. Disc prolapses, reabsorb. The body reabsorbs them. So even if you do have pathology, in the majority cases, the body will do its thing without any serious intervention.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

We are these three dimensional beings, right? You can't just have your psychology dealt with with a psychologist and your biomechanics dealt with with a physiotherapist and your, I don't know, your annual cardiac checks done by the doctor. It doesn't work like that.

Dr. Rangan Chatterjee

When you're getting stuff back, you want more of it. When you're losing stuff, it's very unmotivating.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

If you think that pain means I'm damaged, that's got a whole different meaning. So what we know about pain when it's scary is it's severe, it's uncontrollable, and it's unpredictable. That's what's frightening.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

The system doesn't help, but also our understanding, our beliefs also don't help.

Dr. Rangan Chatterjee

Don't set limits on your life.

Professor Peter O'Sullivan

Cognitive Functional Therapy (CFT) Patient Journey

Professor Peter O'Sullivan
  1. Hear the patient's story to understand their unique experience and validate their pain.
  2. Help the patient understand the factors relevant to their pain, which are different for everyone.
  3. Personalize a program to build confidence in their body, exploring their mood and the activities they cannot do.
  4. Grade the patient back into function, starting gently and gradually building up movement and activity.
  5. Teach the patient to relax their body, re-engage normal movement, and break unhelpful posture rules.
  6. Target activities the patient values (e.g., playing tennis, picking up kids, traveling) to motivate recovery.
  7. Coach the patient over approximately three months, helping them understand drivers of pain (emotional, thoughts, behaviors, lifestyle, sleep, diet).
  8. Empower patients with tools for self-management, including strategies for when pain flare-ups occur.

Managing Pain Flare-ups

Professor Peter O'Sullivan
  1. Identify triggers, which are often stress, fatigue, poor sleep, or inactivity, rather than injury.
  2. Avoid overprotecting or stopping movement, as this is usually unhelpful.
  3. Re-engage in movement, relaxation, and physical activity.
  4. Prioritize good sleep and stress relief strategies.
  5. Use an exacerbation plan to guide actions if pain erupts again.
  6. Contact a clinician if initial self-management steps are not effective.
1 in 5 (20%)
Percentage of people globally affected by chronic pain Leading cause of disability worldwide.
70%
Percentage of people in developed countries who will get lower back pain at some point It's incredibly common, like the flu.
About 1%
Percentage of back pain associated with underlying pathology (e.g., cancer, fracture) Clinicians must screen for these serious but rare conditions.
About 40%
Percentage of people aged 21 with disc degeneration on a scan These are often normal findings in people without pain.
About 20%
Percentage of people aged 21 with disc bulges on a scan These are often normal findings in people without pain.
80%
Percentage of people aged 40 with disc degeneration on a scan Normal age-related changes, not necessarily cause of pain.
60%
Percentage of people aged 40 with disc bulges on a scan Normal age-related changes, not necessarily cause of pain.
30%
Percentage of people aged 40 with disc protrusions on a scan Normal age-related changes, not necessarily cause of pain.
6 months
Duration of Cognitive Functional Therapy training for physiotherapists Involved monthly sessions and real-time work with patients.
About 500
Number of people in the RESTORE trial for Cognitive Functional Therapy People with long-term disabling back pain, aged 18-80s.
58-60%
Percentage of RESTORE trial participants on medication at baseline Many had given up on care before the trial.
Out to three years
Duration of improvement observed after Cognitive Functional Therapy Improvements in disability continued to increase 12 months later, with unpublished data showing lasting effects.
5,000 dollars
Cost saving per person per year by getting back to work after CFT Significant economic benefit from improved function.
600 billion dollars
Annual spending on back pain in the U.S. Despite this, back pain is the largest cause of disability and is getting worse.