The New Science of Awe & How It Improves Your Physical & Mental Wellbeing with Dr Dacher Keltner (re-release) #527
Dr. Dacher Keltner, Professor of Psychology at UC Berkeley, discusses awe as a response to vast, mysterious things, outlining eight types (nature, music, moral beauty, collective effervescence, birth/death). He explains how cultivating awe offers profound health benefits like reduced inflammation and stress, and fosters meaning and humility.
Deep Dive Analysis
14 Topic Outline
Introduction to Awe and its Role in Happiness
Happiness Beyond Materialism: Money, Meaning, and Connection
Defining Awe: Vastness, Mystery, and Emotion
The Eight Paths to Experiencing Awe
Scientific Benefits of Awe for Health and Well-being
Music as a Powerful and Accessible Source of Awe
Collective Effervescence: Shared Movement and Consciousness
Impact of Technology on Collective Awe Experiences
Practicing Awe: The Awe Walk and Cultivating Humility
Life and Death as Profound Triggers for Awe
Embracing Uncertainty and the Cycle of Life and Death
Cultural Perspectives on Awe and Collective Experience
Cultivating Everyday Awe as a Trainable Skill
Final Advice: Finding Awe for Health and Well-being
6 Key Concepts
Happiness (2023 perspective)
Happiness is increasingly understood as a quest for meaning, shifting from earlier views focused on individual purpose and pleasure, in response to global challenges and a collective moment of reflection.
Awe
Awe is an emotion experienced in response to powerful things that are vast, mysterious, and beyond one's current frame of reference, making one feel small and filled with wonder. It is considered a basic state of mind that shapes how we experience the world.
Eight Wonders (Paths to Awe)
These are common and easily available categories through which people around the world experience awe. They include moral beauty, nature, collective movement, music, visual design, spirituality, epiphanies (big ideas), and life and death.
Collective Effervescence
A term coined by Emile Durkheim, it describes the profound feeling of unity and shared consciousness that arises when people move in unison, synchronize their actions, and share attention, often leading to an electric, ecstatic emotional experience.
Humility
Humility is characterized by a realistic assessment of one's own strengths and weaknesses, coupled with an openness and appreciation for the strengths of others. Experiencing awe can help cultivate humility by making the self feel smaller in the face of something vast.
Wabi-sabi
A Japanese aesthetic principle that embraces the beauty of imperfection, impermanence, and incompleteness. It reflects the natural cycle of creation, birth, growth, decay, and death in all forms, from natural phenomena to man-made objects.
7 Questions Answered
Happiness is increasingly understood as a quest for meaning, moving beyond earlier focuses on individual pleasure and economic expansion, especially in light of current global challenges and a collective moment of reflection.
Awe offers a suite of benefits, including reducing inflammation, activating the vagus nerve, calming stress regions in the brain like the amygdala, improving clear and creative thinking, and reducing physical pain, even with just five minutes of experience.
Awe is considered a basic state of mind that, like other emotions, shapes how we experience the world and derive meaning, and it can be studied scientifically through its neurophysiological pathways and expressions.
While smartphones can't fully deliver the vastness needed for direct awe experiences, they can interfere with collective effervescence by distracting individuals from shared attention and present-moment engagement. However, they can also facilitate awe by allowing us to revisit awe-inspiring memories or content in a quiet, reflective setting.
Awe is a trainable skill that can be cultivated by actively seeking out and reflecting on the 'eight wonders' in everyday life, such as listening to music, going for an 'awe walk,' observing nature, or reflecting on acts of moral beauty.
Death, despite its pain and horror, can be awe-inspiring as it confronts us with profound mysteries about life, purpose, and what lies beyond, often leading to existential questions and a deeper appreciation for life and connection.
Their humility may stem from experiencing awe through their sport, which connects them to the vastness of nature (running outdoors), the history of their sport, and the collective inspiration they provide to thousands of people, making them feel part of something much larger than themselves.
39 Actionable Insights
1. Shift Focus from Self to Awe
Actively seek out experiences of awe to counteract excessive self-focus, which is identified as a root cause of many modern health challenges, by shifting your attention outside of yourself.
2. Redefine Happiness as Meaning
Shift your understanding of happiness from individual pleasure to a quest for meaning and purpose in your life, especially given current global challenges.
3. Prioritize Meaning Over Materialism
Focus on finding meaning in life that transcends transactional values and money, as this pursuit is crucial for improving your overall life expectancy and well-being.
4. Cultivate Social Connections
Actively foster and maintain social connections and embed yourself in a community, as this significantly contributes to happiness and can add up to 10 years to your life expectancy.
5. Actively Cultivate Happiness
Make a conscious effort to cultivate happiness through various practices, as extensive research shows it can add approximately seven to eight years to your life expectancy.
6. Regularly Experience Awe for Health
Intentionally seek out moments of awe, even for just five minutes, to gain a suite of health benefits including reduced inflammation, activated vagal tone, lower stress, clearer thinking, increased creativity, and reduced physical pain (especially for older adults).
7. Perceive Everyday Awe
Recognize that awe is present in everyday life and interactions; train yourself to actively look for and perceive these moments of wonder.
8. Embrace Mystery and Uncertainty
Cultivate the ability to sit with and embrace uncertainty and mystery in life, rather than seeking precise definitions or complete control, as this is a fundamental aspect of wonder.
9. Explore Eight Paths to Awe
Actively seek awe through its eight identified pathways: moral beauty (kindness/courage), nature, collective movement, music, visual design, spirituality, epiphanies (big ideas), and life and death.
10. Integrate Brief Awe Moments Daily
Incorporate small, three to five-minute shifts into your daily routine to experience awe, such as sitting in a garden during lunch, taking a short walk with colleagues, or sharing awe stories, as these are easy to do and provide benefits.
11. Practice Weekly Awe Walks
Engage in a weekly ‘awe walk’ by visiting a slightly mysterious place and intentionally observing both small details and vast elements of your surroundings, which can reduce distress and increase feelings of awe.
12. Observe Nature for Brief Periods
Take one to two minutes to observe natural elements like trees, sunsets, or clouds, focusing on details and movement, as even short periods of observation can reduce narcissism, entitlement, and increase altruism.
13. Reflect on Nature’s Temporal Vastness
When observing nature, reflect on its vastness across time, considering its age and how it connects to past generations, to foster a sense of being part of something much greater than your individual existence.
14. Re-engage with Meaningful Music
Revisit music from your past that evoked strong emotions or a sense of wonder, as re-listening to these songs can reconnect you to visceral awe and its associated benefits.
15. Daily Awe Through Music
Dedicate a short period, like 10 minutes daily, to listen to music that gives you goosebumps or a profound sense of awe, as this is an easy and effective way to gain its benefits.
16. Engage in Collective Effervescence
Seek out experiences of collective effervescence by engaging in synchronized movements with others, such as dancing, cheering at sports events, or participating in communal rituals, to foster shared consciousness and a sense of unity.
17. Prioritize In-Person Group Activities
While online activities can be convenient, prioritize attending in-person group classes or events (e.g., yoga, hobbies) at least once a week to foster community, meet like-minded people, and combat loneliness, as online solitary activities do not compare to collective engagement.
18. Reduce Self-Focus Through Others
Combat mental health challenges by reducing excessive self-focus and actively engaging with other people in physical settings, as awe and genuine connection are not typically found through solitary use of Zoom or smartphones.
19. Be Fully Present in Collective Moments
Avoid distractions like cell phones during collective experiences (e.g., watching children perform) to ensure your awareness is fully present and shared with others, allowing for a deeper experience of awe.
20. Seek Awe in Vast Real-World Experiences
Recognize that true awe, particularly the sense of vastness, is difficult to experience directly through a smartphone; instead, seek out real-world experiences that offer visual and temporal vastness.
21. Use Technology to Revisit Awe Memories
Utilize smartphones or other technology to revisit past awe-inspiring memories, such as listening to meaningful music or viewing images of grand architecture, ideally in a quiet place, to re-evoke those feelings.
22. Find Awe in Hardship
Recognize that awe can emerge from grappling with struggle, suffering, and pain, and can inspire you to seek ways to improve situations or build community, even in difficult circumstances.
23. Practice Three Principles for Dying
When confronting death, adopt three principles: accept uncertainty and mystery, simply witness the process without trying to control or label it, and engage in compassionate action by being kind rather than trying to fix or mislead.
24. Cultivate Awe When Facing Terminal Illness
When facing a terminal illness, cultivate a sense of awe about the experience, as this can help you feel connected to a broader human experience and family, providing comfort and a sense of meaning.
25. Allow Awe to Guide Through Grief
Recognize that grief, despite its pain, contains elements of mystery and vastness; allow awe to guide you through these mysteries, helping you navigate the process.
26. Embrace Life’s Cycle of Decay
Embrace the natural cycle of creation, birth, growth, decay, and death (wabi-sabi), rather than resisting it, as this perspective can bring comfort and a sense of awe in understanding life’s broader evolution.
27. Reflect on Your Place in Systems
When experiencing awe, ask yourself what larger system you are a part of (e.g., fellow humans, an ecosystem, culture), to realize your small but connected place within something vast.
28. Cultivate Humility for Success
Recognize that humility, defined as a realistic assessment of oneself and openness to others’ strengths, is a pathway to enduring success and can be fostered through awe experiences.
29. Embrace Parenthood’s Self-Transcendence
Understand and embrace parenthood as a profoundly transformative experience that naturally takes you outside of yourself, shifting focus from individual worries to broader responsibilities and a new sense of purpose.
30. Approach Childbirth with Awe
Adopt an awe-based approach to childbirth, being fully aware of the experience and understanding its vastness and profound significance.
31. Reflect on Moral Beauty of Mentors
Engage in an exercise of reflecting on a mentor whose kindness or courage profoundly impacted your life, recognizing their moral beauty and how their influence continues with you today, as this can evoke awe.
32. Engage with Meaningful Ideas, Texts
Actively seek out and engage with ideas and texts (e.g., literature, philosophy) that resonate with you and help you reflect on life’s bigger questions, fostering a sense of awe and personal spirituality.
33. Practice Life Trajectory Reflection
Regularly practice imagining the full life trajectory of someone you deeply care about, from their birth to their death, to cultivate appreciation for their journey and find awe in the natural cycle of life.
34. Seek Awe Through Secular Rituals
For those who are not religious, actively seek to build a sense of awe through secular rituals, communal activities (e.g., singing together), and engagement with inspiring texts or art, mimicking the awe-generating aspects of religion.
35. Practice Regular Contemplative Activities
Engage in a regular contemplative practice, such as meditation, to cultivate a heightened awareness that allows you to perceive awe and wonder in everyday life, even outside of your dedicated practice time.
36. Cultivate Everyday Awe and Wonder
Make a conscious effort to cultivate awe and wonder in your daily life by engaging in simple practices like listening to music, taking an awe walk, reading inspiring poetry, or observing children, as it is readily accessible.
37. Minimize Commute Time
Be aware that long commutes, often associated with buying a nicer home, can significantly undermine your happiness, suggesting a need to prioritize proximity over property size if happiness is the goal.
38. Discourage Youth Materialism
Recognize that pressuring high school students and teenagers to pursue materialism does not bring them happiness but actively undermines it, suggesting a need to guide them towards other values.
39. Engage in Pro-Social Behaviors
Regularly practice gratitude, spend time outdoors for walks, and engage in giving or serving others and charity, as these actions are linked to significant increases in life expectancy.
5 Key Quotes
Awe occurs in a realm separate from the mundane world of materialism, money, acquisition, and status signaling, a realm beyond the profane that many call the sacred.
Dacher Keltner
I look around me and the people are dancing, you know, and it's just joy.
Steve Kerr (as quoted by Dacher Keltner)
The people we love remain with us in even more mysterious ways after they leave.
Dacher Keltner
Religions are just containers for awe.
Dacher Keltner
There's everyday awe and wonder, just go get it, you know?
Dacher Keltner
2 Protocols
Awe Walk
Dacher Keltner- Go to someplace that is a little mysterious.
- Look at small things, like a rock on a table.
- Look at vast things, like an entire studio or the whole sky.
- Reflect on how small you are in comparison to the vastness.
- Take selfies where your self appears smaller and fades to the side, taking in more of the environment (optional, for study purposes).
Three Principles for Facing the End of Life
Roshi Joan Halifax (as described by Dacher Keltner)- Accept uncertainty, mystery, and not knowing about the process of dying and what comes after.
- Witness the process by observing without trying to direct, control, or label, simply being present.
- Engage in compassionate action, which means being kind and supportive rather than attempting to control or mislead.