#068 Dr. Bill Harris on the Omega-3 Index: Increasing Omega-3 to Promote Longevity & Transform Health

Sep 10, 2021 Episode Page ↗
Overview

Dr. William Harris, co-inventor of the Omega-3 Index, discusses marine omega-3s' critical role in cardiovascular and neurocognitive health. He covers the Omega-3 Index as a modifiable risk factor for all-cause mortality, its correlation with inflammation, and implications for COVID-19 outcomes.

At a Glance
14 Insights
1h 58m Duration
17 Topics
5 Concepts

Deep Dive Analysis

Dr. Harris's Early Research on Omega-3s and Triglycerides

Omega-3s and Bleeding Risk: Historical Context and Modern Findings

Distinguishing Plant-Based (ALA) from Marine Omega-3s (EPA/DHA)

Future of Sustainable Omega-3 Production through Genetic Engineering

Introduction to the Omega-3 Index: A Cardiovascular Risk Factor

Measuring Omega-3 Status: Red Blood Cells vs. Plasma

Individual Variability in Omega-3 Levels and Supplement Response

Challenges in Omega-3 Clinical Trial Design and Interpretation

Omega-3 Index Predicts All-Cause Mortality and Lifespan

Systemic Anti-Inflammatory and Pro-Resolving Effects of Omega-3s

Omega-3s, Red Blood Cell Biology, and Cardiovascular Protection

Omega-3 Index and COVID-19 Mortality Risk

DHA's Potential Role in Blocking SARS-CoV-2 Spike Protein Entry

Revisiting the Omega-6 to Omega-3 Ratio: Focus on Omega-3 Intake

Addressing Concerns about Omega-3s and Prostate Cancer

Optimal Omega-3 Dosing and Atrial Fibrillation Risk

Omega-3s for Brain Health, Alzheimer's Prevention, and Development

Omega-3 Index

The Omega-3 Index is a measure of the percentage of EPA and DHA in red blood cell membranes, reflecting long-term omega-3 status. It was proposed as a modifiable risk factor for cardiovascular disease, similar to cholesterol levels.

Specialized Pro-Resolving Mediators (SPMs)

SPMs are molecules made from EPA and DHA that actively suppress and resolve inflammation once it starts. They are crucial for shutting down inflammatory responses, preventing them from spiraling out of control and contributing to chronic inflammation.

Red Cell Distribution Width (RDW)

RDW is a measure of the variation in the size of red blood cells in the blood. A higher RDW (more varied cell sizes) is a significant predictor of adverse health outcomes, and a healthier, lower RDW is associated with higher omega-3 levels.

Alpha-Linolenic Acid (ALA)

ALA is a plant-based omega-3 fatty acid, typically 18 carbons long, found in sources like chia seeds and walnuts. While it shares structural similarities with marine omega-3s, its conversion to EPA and DHA in the body is very limited (2-5%), making it less potent for cardioprotective benefits.

EPA and DHA

Eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and Docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) are the longer-chain marine omega-3 fatty acids, 20 and 22 carbons long respectively. They are primarily found in fish and algae and are responsible for most of the well-documented health benefits associated with omega-3s, including cardiovascular protection and anti-inflammatory effects.

?
What initially sparked Dr. Harris's interest in omega-3 fatty acids?

Dr. Harris began studying omega-3s in the late 1970s as part of a postdoc project to investigate how fish oil, an animal fat that is liquid at room temperature, affected cholesterol levels, leading to the unexpected discovery of its triglyceride-lowering effects.

?
Are plant-based omega-3s (ALA) as effective as marine omega-3s (EPA and DHA) for cardiovascular health?

No, plant-based ALA is not nearly as potent as marine EPA and DHA for cardioprotective benefits. While ALA can convert to EPA and DHA, the conversion rate is very low (around 2-5%), making direct consumption of marine sources or algal oil more effective.

?
What is the Omega-3 Index and why is it considered a better long-term marker than plasma omega-3 levels?

The Omega-3 Index measures EPA and DHA in red blood cell membranes, providing a stable, long-term reflection of omega-3 status. Unlike plasma levels, which can fluctuate daily with meals, the red blood cell measure is more consistent, similar to how hemoglobin A1C reflects long-term glucose control.

?
What is the recommended target Omega-3 Index level for optimal health?

The recommended target Omega-3 Index level is above 8%. Studies have shown that individuals with an index over 7-8% have significantly lower risks for various adverse health outcomes, including all-cause mortality.

?
How does the Omega-3 Index relate to overall life expectancy?

Studies, including one from the Framingham cohort, suggest that individuals with the highest Omega-3 Index levels (e.g., over 7%) may live approximately five years longer than those with the lowest levels (e.g., under 4%).

?
Can omega-3s help reduce inflammation?

Yes, omega-3s, particularly EPA and DHA, are known to reduce and resolve inflammation. They are metabolized into specialized pro-resolving mediators (SPMs) that actively suppress inflammatory responses and prevent them from becoming chronic.

?
What is the relationship between the Omega-3 Index and COVID-19 mortality?

A pilot study found that COVID-19 patients with the highest quartile of omega-3 levels were half as likely to die compared to those with lower levels. Additionally, in silico experiments suggest DHA may help keep the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in a closed position, preventing it from entering cells.

?
Is the omega-6 to omega-3 ratio a reliable indicator of health?

The omega-6 to omega-3 ratio is considered imprecise and potentially misleading. While a high ratio can be 'fixed' by increasing omega-3 intake, simply lowering omega-6 intake without increasing omega-3 does not necessarily improve health, and some omega-6 fatty acids like linoleic acid are associated with lower cardiovascular and diabetes risk.

?
Does omega-3 supplementation increase the risk of prostate cancer?

No, concerns linking omega-3s to prostate cancer stem from a single, highly criticized 2013 study that found a very small, statistically significant correlation in a confounded cohort. This finding has not been confirmed and has been refuted by other studies showing omega-3s to be protective against prostate cancer.

?
What is the current understanding of omega-3s and atrial fibrillation (Afib) risk?

Some high-dose omega-3 trials (e.g., 4 grams/day) have shown a small, statistically significant increase in Afib risk in individuals with pre-existing heart conditions. However, lower doses (e.g., 800mg) have not shown this risk, and observational studies suggest higher baseline omega-3 levels may be associated with a lower risk of Afib.

?
How do omega-3s contribute to red blood cell health and oxygen delivery?

Omega-3s, particularly DHA, increase the flexibility of red blood cell membranes. This enhanced flexibility allows red blood cells to more efficiently squeeze through capillaries and potentially deliver more oxygen to tissues, which may be a protective mechanism against various adverse outcomes.

?
What role do omega-3s play in pregnancy and child development?

Omega-3 supplementation during pregnancy, particularly DHA, has been shown to reduce the risk of premature birth, especially early premature birth (before 34 weeks). Maintaining a red blood cell DHA level over 5% is suggested as a target for pregnant women to potentially reduce this risk and support fetal brain development.

1. Achieve Optimal Omega-3 Index

Get your omega-3 index measured (via red blood cell analysis) and aim for a target level over 8% to reflect long-term omega-3 status and reduce overall health risks.

2. Increase Omega-3 Intake Daily

Consistently consume more omega-3s through diet (fatty fish like salmon, sardines) or supplements to raise your omega-3 levels and reduce the risk of various diseases and all-cause mortality.

3. Prioritize Marine Omega-3 Sources

Focus on consuming marine-based omega-3s (EPA and DHA) from fish or algal oil, as plant-based alpha-linolenic acid (ALA) is not as potent for cardioprotective benefits.

4. Boost Omega-3 for Inflammation

Increase your omega-3 intake to lower inflammatory biomarkers and promote the active resolution of inflammation, which is crucial for preventing chronic disease.

5. Omega-3 for Brain Health

Maintain a high omega-3 index to potentially reduce the risk of Alzheimer’s and dementia, with benefits appearing stronger for individuals at higher genetic risk (e.g., APOE4 carriers).

6. Omega-3 for Pregnancy Outcomes

Pregnant women should take omega-3 supplements to reduce the risk of premature birth, especially early premature birth before 34 weeks, as supported by meta-analyses.

7. Monitor DHA in Pregnancy

Pregnant women should consider measuring their red cell DHA levels and aim for an omega-3 index over 5% to help reduce the risk of preterm birth.

8. Supplement if Diet Insufficient

If consistent dietary intake of omega-3s is challenging, utilize supplements as a practical and effective way to ensure adequate omega-3 levels.

9. Titrate Omega-3 Dosage

Adjust omega-3 dosage based on individual blood level measurements (e.g., omega-3 index), as there is significant variability in how people respond to supplementation.

10. Omega-3 and Red Blood Cells

Maintain high omega-3 levels to enhance the flexibility of red blood cell membranes, which may improve oxygen delivery to tissues and contribute to overall health.

11. Focus on Omega-3 Intake

Prioritize increasing your omega-3 intake rather than solely focusing on reducing omega-6 intake to improve the omega-3 to omega-6 ratio for health benefits.

12. Omega-3 Bleeding Concerns

Do not be overly concerned about omega-3s causing clinically significant bleeding, as regulatory bodies like the FDA state prescription omega-3s do not; however, monitoring is standard if on blood thinners.

13. Omega-3 for COVID-19

While not statistically significant in a pilot study, maintaining higher omega-3 levels was associated with a lower risk of mortality from COVID-19, suggesting a potential protective role.

14. Omega-3 and Smoking Risk

While not a substitute for quitting, maintaining a high omega-3 level may reduce the risk of death for smokers, though the best outcome is achieved by not smoking and having high omega-3.

If you don't measure it, you can't control it, right? Manage it.

Dr. Bill Harris

The problem is that you can fix a bad ratio by taking more omega-3. And that's the right way to do it. But you cannot fix it and improve your health by leaving your omega-3 intake alone and just lowering your omega-6.

Dr. Bill Harris

I mean, it's silly to think you can take somebody who's 65 years old and who's had a crappy diet their whole life and put them in an omega-3 trial. Give them 840 milligrams of omega-3, like one capsule of Lodeza, and expect in three years to see a difference in cardiovascular endpoints. I mean, it's just ridiculous.

Dr. Bill Harris

It's not just heart disease. I think that's the message to get out. It's not just heart disease.

Dr. Bill Harris

As much as we in nutrition would love to say, get it from food, we're real. You got to be realistic. Some people are not going to do it. And so you don't withhold plan B, which is take it from supplements.

Dr. Bill Harris
20%
Omega-3 content in salmon oil As fish oils go, it's a fairly low omega-3 oil.
25%
Triglyceride reduction in normal, healthy volunteers on high fish oil diet From an average of 100 down to 75; statistically significant but clinically meaningless for normal individuals.
80%
Triglyceride reduction in hyperlipidemic patients on high fish oil diet Observed in patients with very high triglycerides (Type 5 hyperlipidemic).
17 years
Years of follow-up in the Physician's Health Study for sudden cardiac death Study that linked high blood omega-3 levels to reduced risk of sudden cardiac arrest.
90%
Reduction in sudden cardiac arrest risk for men with highest omega-3 levels Observed in the Physician's Health Study.
120 days
Red blood cell turnover time This contributes to the Omega-3 Index being a long-term marker.
5%
Average Omega-3 Index in Americans Expressed as EPA+DHA in red cells as a percent of total fatty acids.
8-10%
Average Omega-3 Index in Japan Due to higher fish intake.
3.5-4%
Average Omega-3 Index in vegans and US military personnel Indicates low omega-3 intake.
8%
Target Omega-3 Index level Considered the goal for optimal health and reduced risk.
15-16%
Upper range of Omega-3 Index typically observed Rarely seen above 20%, even in marine mammals like dolphins.
15%
Reduction in all-cause mortality for highest vs. lowest omega-3 levels Observed in a pooled analysis of 17 cohorts over a specific age window (65-75 years).
5 years
Difference in lifespan between lowest and highest omega-3 levels Roughly estimated from the Framingham study for all-cause mortality.
100-150 milligrams
Average daily intake of EPA and DHA in America Median intake is zero; average is skewed by some high consumers.
900 milligrams
Average daily intake of EPA and DHA in Japan Contributes to their higher average lifespan.
25%
Reduction in cardiovascular events with 4 grams of EPA (Vasepa) Observed in the REDUCE-IT trial.
840 milligrams
Dose of omega-3 in the VITAL study A relatively low dose, equivalent to one capsule of Lovasa.
70 trials
Number of trials in Cochrane report on omega-3 and pregnancy Meta-analysis concluded omega-3 reduces risk for premature birth.
Over 5%
Target red blood cell DHA level for pregnant women Associated with reduced risk for preterm birth.